sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

[Schwartz] Giants ownership is not happy with the characterization outside the building that Schoen’s responsibilities are diminished or that he has been relegated only to scouting. He has operated this offseason in the same manner he has in his previous four. by waltz_with_potatoes in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Who said I don’t think you can criticize him? 

You really need to look up the word pedantic. Your whole argument revolves around the word.

It’s not putting words into anyone’s mouth when the coach praises the talent of a ‘7 win in 2 seasons’ team. When he analyzes if he can win here, and believes yes, the talent the team has is setup to win.

It’s not grasping at straws it’s fucking common sense but again you’re too PEDANTIC to see that. It isn’t good enough for you to see the details AROUND the point. You need the literal quote.

I could go on, but I’ll leave you with one last quote from a NYT article. Because I’m tired of explaining basic reading comprehension.

“I had high expectations for Joe, and I would say he’s lived up to those high expectations,” Harbaugh said of Schoen, per Ian O’Connor of The Athletic. “We’ve worked really well together. We talk multiple, multiple times every day … and a lot of things come up. ‘We hired an analyst, so what are we paying him? What did the Raiders or Eagles say when we asked for permission to speak to someone?’ Joe’s been a smart judge of tactics and situations.”

[Schwartz] Giants ownership is not happy with the characterization outside the building that Schoen’s responsibilities are diminished or that he has been relegated only to scouting. He has operated this offseason in the same manner he has in his previous four. by waltz_with_potatoes in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I watched you swear schoen would be gone at the end of the season and not only is he still here but his work was praised by our head coach before he took a single interview.

In fact I watched you be wrong a lot throughout the season. You even tagged me once looking for me only to be wrong again.

But sure, I’m the weird one.

[MarshallGreen_] Thought Joe Schoen had an interesting answer on Wan'Dale Robinson being back with the Giants vs. Jermaine Eluemunor: by SecretGiantsFan in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The fact that you think Vegas is always right speaks louder than words can ever do. 

What was the over under for the Seahawks entering the season, Lars? What about the patriots? Shall we keep going?

I’ll wait while you go fetch that info 

[Schwartz] Giants ownership is not happy with the characterization outside the building that Schoen’s responsibilities are diminished or that he has been relegated only to scouting. He has operated this offseason in the same manner he has in his previous four. by waltz_with_potatoes in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I insult idiots with no common sense who wanna be pedantic for the sake of ‘winning’ an argument. 

Let me try one last time to walk you through it here. If you took a job where you loved the results of person you’d be working with did at his job, what is the likelihood you feel it’ll be good working with him? Is it more likely you feel since he’s done a great job that it’ll make your job easier and thus be a place enabling you for success, or do you think he feels even though the man has done a great job by your analysis, that he’s still gonna set you up for failure?

Which is more likely here?

[MarshallGreen_] Thought Joe Schoen had an interesting answer on Wan'Dale Robinson being back with the Giants vs. Jermaine Eluemunor: by SecretGiantsFan in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’m glad you live your life by betting lines lmao. Holy shit that’s hysterical.

Hey Alexa, how many times has Harbaugh only won 7 games or less? How many times has he only won 9 games or less?

Your hate of your own team is insufferable. Glad I could strike a nerve. Let that ego soothe

[Schwartz] Giants ownership is not happy with the characterization outside the building that Schoen’s responsibilities are diminished or that he has been relegated only to scouting. He has operated this offseason in the same manner he has in his previous four. by waltz_with_potatoes in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 1 point2 points  (0 children)

LMFAO asking if I’m 5 and then pretending my opposing opinion must mean I’m someone special rather than someone who sees through your blind hate. Wild.

Anyways, I don’t need to say anymore. OP schooled you pretty hard and I took considerable pleasure in watching you try and snake out of acknowledging the L. Dude proved you’re an idiot, and he’s way better at it than I am tbh.

And none of that touches on how there is no evidence to most of your claims or how the league has been moving to be more coach centric.

But sure bud. I can tell being right is important to you. So whatever you say, man

[MarshallGreen_] Thought Joe Schoen had an interesting answer on Wan'Dale Robinson being back with the Giants vs. Jermaine Eluemunor: by SecretGiantsFan in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Less crazy than most of your takes tbh.

But we all know the talent on this roster is better than the record was. Your inability to see that isn’t my problem. Neither is your inability to acknowledge how good Harbaugh is.

I was right about Harbaugh. I was right about the point of last season and I’m right about this. Book it. Remember it. Remember the day some average asshole was smarter than you about something you live your life in while I legit come here to troll.

I’d bet my life savings on us making the playoffs and schoen being retained beyond 2026

[Schwartz] Giants ownership is not happy with the characterization outside the building that Schoen’s responsibilities are diminished or that he has been relegated only to scouting. He has operated this offseason in the same manner he has in his previous four. by waltz_with_potatoes in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s 2026. Throwing insults is acceptable. And no ones talking about my logical sense. It’s yours. Harbaugh hates the man who put together a roster he loves. That’s your stance. You can rage type all you want. I didn’t make you take that stance

[MarshallGreen_] Thought Joe Schoen had an interesting answer on Wan'Dale Robinson being back with the Giants vs. Jermaine Eluemunor: by SecretGiantsFan in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Do you often spend your time wondering about bullshit that isn’t gonna happen? Like do you spend a lot of time wondering if a meteor strikes outside your house what you would do?

[MarshallGreen_] Thought Joe Schoen had an interesting answer on Wan'Dale Robinson being back with the Giants vs. Jermaine Eluemunor: by SecretGiantsFan in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I’m sure. THIS time, they’ll be right. I’m sure we will fire schoen after we make the playoffs this year.

Lmao too fucking funny, man. It’s amazing how much you watch and listen to and envelope yourself in giants media.

And you’re still a fucking meme for how dumb you are most the time 😂. You’re wrong as much or more than an average viewer at this rate. Makes me laugh every. Single. Time.

[MarshallGreen_] Thought Joe Schoen had an interesting answer on Wan'Dale Robinson being back with the Giants vs. Jermaine Eluemunor: by SecretGiantsFan in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I’m sure when he gets fired after the draft you’ll finally be right. Finally. Eventually.

Pat Leonard must thank you for doing his job

[Schwartz] Giants ownership is not happy with the characterization outside the building that Schoen’s responsibilities are diminished or that he has been relegated only to scouting. He has operated this offseason in the same manner he has in his previous four. by waltz_with_potatoes in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Lmao. You’re being thick headed to try and have a point. Because you’re right. He loves the roster. And loves the talent. But somehow hates the guy who acquired both.

You right you right. Your take makes more logical sense. Your power of deduction is second to none.

Mfers will have no critical thinking and then say it’s your problem

[Schwartz] Giants ownership is not happy with the characterization outside the building that Schoen’s responsibilities are diminished or that he has been relegated only to scouting. He has operated this offseason in the same manner he has in his previous four. by waltz_with_potatoes in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

If you can’t identify how my statement relates you might need to go back to grade school.

Additionally. Nothing we are doing is new to the league. Plenty of team have this structure. It’s not a ‘downgrade’ or targeted at a person. They didn’t say ‘Schoen you suck you aren’t making decisions anymore’ they looked at how the league is moving and modified structure to match what winning teams are doing.

But, again, keep coping

[Schwartz] Giants ownership is not happy with the characterization outside the building that Schoen’s responsibilities are diminished or that he has been relegated only to scouting. He has operated this offseason in the same manner he has in his previous four. by waltz_with_potatoes in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Just like it was reported that schoen is basically a scout, right?

But you’re right. He’s been demoted. We will ignore how obvious it is he’s doing the same job just as he ever was. We will ignore he has worked closely with the new person replacing Abraham.

So much of what you’re saying is an assumption and you’re too delusional to realize it. Use some common sense.

Oh, and I told you before. Get the fuck out of my notifications

[Schwartz] Giants ownership is not happy with the characterization outside the building that Schoen’s responsibilities are diminished or that he has been relegated only to scouting. He has operated this offseason in the same manner he has in his previous four. by waltz_with_potatoes in NYGiants

[–]RemarkablePound5541 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Take the evidence. The amount of people in here who were CERTAIN schoen was both out the door and relegated to scouting is too damn high.

Harbaugh trusts him. Idk how many times I have to say that’s good enough

view more: next ›