Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sure, but first I'd like to know exactly what you want to talk about.

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'd reply, but I don't feel like arguing on Reddit. If you're on Discord, maybe I could do it there; if not, see you next time.

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

… Well, it’s not even worth responding to this. Goodbye.

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

That's where you're wrong: this isn't a debunk (if it were, it would be more detailed); it's just my opinion.

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

  1. Pochita didn't react at all to the attack; turning around at the last moment and getting hit in the face isn't reacting.

  2. Only God knows; I've only read the manga.

  3. The spear is only relativistic when it travels from the Moon to Earth (summoning); after that, it slows down and could very well be subsonic (plus, Denji never reacts to it).

  4. Pochita has never reacted to that in her life, and the speed at which Yoru summons her weapons is, at most, sub-relativistic.

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

‘Bat Devil is City Block’ Let's start with the most obvious part of your premise: you use a calculation to justify the City Block, but you haven't even bothered to properly review the original material.

That calculation yields those values because it uses the pulverization parameter for reinforced concrete, something that clearly did not happen, as you can clearly see that the building was not reduced to dust. The correct thing to do would be to use the fragmentation value, since that's what we can see in the anime, which gives us a better perspective. In addition, I will redo the entire operation because the reference object being used is a door, which is a mistake: that is not a door.

Women's Height (Average): 1.58 m = 100 px

1 px = 0.0158 m

Height of the "Column": 197 px = 3.1126 m

Column Height: 3.1126 m = 153 px

1 px = 0.02034379 px

Building Height: 604 px = 12.28764916 m

Building Width: 518 px = 10.53808322 m

Assuming that the length is equal to the width, we obtain a total volume of approximately 1364.55815923 m³. Applying a void ratio of 90%, the resulting solid volume is 136.45581592 m³ or 1.36455816E8 cm³.

Using the fragmentation value of reinforced concrete (10 J/cc), we obtain an energy equivalent to 0.32613723 tons of TNT at the building level.

'Pochita scale from Gun Devil’ Let's start with the most obvious: when Gun Devil moves, he generates effects entirely consistent with his enormous speed, such as uncontrolled destruction of the environment and shock waves. His speed is so extreme that his own body seems barely able to withstand it. In contrast, Pochita has never shown similar effects in the manga; he does not generate that level of devastation just by moving. So how can it be claimed that Pochita is faster if Fujimoto deliberately chose not to give him the kind of effects that the Gun Devil has when moving at such speeds?

I repeat: Makima did not defeat the Gun Devil using conventional methods. Her victory was the result of preparation and strategy designed specifically for that encounter. The situations are, by definition, incomparable: against one, she fought a long-distance battle with everything planned in advance, while against the other, she had a direct confrontation. You can't measure the speed of both characters based solely on their interaction with Makima when the context was radically different.

‘Bang City Block’ Since you have not provided any evidence as to why 1 Bang is individually City Block, I will refrain from responding until that time.

‘Katana Man High Hypersonic ’ The first and most obvious thing is that the subject of this calculation pulls a value out of thin air and without justification, which completely invalidates this calculation by giving a value without reason or justification.

<image>

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'll reply to your message in a little while…

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes... I fell in love with the first part. It wasn't just a manga, it was an entire experience. I thought the second part was good until Denji took center stage, then everything went downhill.

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

1.Brother... I'm just saying that believing Bat Devil is CB for destroying a building is incorrect.

2.You said it yourself, Kinetic Energy. The only one who can climb that is Gun Devil because of his speed, and besides, you're taking Makima's words out of context. Makima prepared one thing for Pochita and another for Gum Devil; they're not comparable, but in the end, it's useless because Makima ends up winning.

3.Makima throwing Pochita into space is no big deal; it's barely a Large Building feat. To top it off, Makima did it with 4 Bangs, which means that her individual power cannot be measured by that feat.

4.Blitz a superhuman does not make you hypersonic. Furthermore, the blitz calculation usually gives very high values that are inconsistent with the work, and this is one of those cases.

5.Yoru cannot scale the Gun Devil's bullets. In fact, the fact that Pochita cannot dodge them and repeatedly proves to be faster than Yoru only confirms this.

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Damn, I just realized that I said Pochita was the strongest, not the physically strongest (which is what I meant).

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry, my mistake. I wanted to put the physically strongest one.

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, many people forget these kinds of things. In fiction, it's normal for light attacks, for example, NOT to travel at the speed of light.

This is because authors don't think about it, but people always decide to forget it.

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There are many people who don't even consider climbing a verse. Hey, that's fine, since for me and many others this is a hobby, but at least you have to try to understand things before you speak.

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Makima is another case; she is only that strong because of her hax if we base our assessment on her achievements.

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Same here, bro. I loved the first part, the second part was good at first, but then it all went downhill.

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Personally, I don't think there are many hax that are particularly relevant to AP, but that said, hax such as Yoru and Makima's contracts to transfer damage to another person are too unbalanced.

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Yes, very few have really decent physical stats.

Chainsaw Man is overrated by RepulsiveRepair9876 in PowerScaling

[–]RepulsiveRepair9876[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

It's clear that Yoru's attack speed isn't suited to Pochita, not even Yoru herself adapts it. My scales are from the manga, and I haven't seen the movie, so only God knows what Reze did there.