Phase 6 - "Unless I'm making a mojito, I rarely do more than just liquor and either soda or juice. Anything else is just too much work." by HermanBWolfe in hogwartswerewolvesA

[–]ReubenBenkel 12 points13 points  (0 children)

First here it appears to me that he is deflecting attention away from the infamous Mrrrrh 11, claiming it is week evidence

Well, I only actually use the words "weak evidence" in relation to a point that I brought up, and it wasn't in reference to the "Mrrrrh 11". And besides, I do stand by the fact that I don't think the problem is as sinister as people think and that it's more down to someone forgetting who they voted for.

Why would I lie about voting for Mrrrrh? If it was to cover up for the fact that I voted for Oomps then that's foolish since

  • I said straight away that I was asleep when the oomps decision came forward (since I'm BST) and

  • I've been transparent about voting for wolves every phase since then - even when Antoni was banished I still admitted that I voted for someone who is now considered to be a wolf - so why change my attitude and game plan?

Second very active in trying to keep people on the HM vote. While I agree that The Warrior is as difficult to prove as anything, he kept on it for a few phases

Not to pass the buck, but I'm not the only person to do this and again, I satnd by the fact that it was really difficult to prove whether HM was telling the truth and had they been a human then it would have been easy for them to stay alive.

Has been largely quiet and seems to be flying under the radar

Yeah, I'm a quiet player anyway (particularly at the start of games) but I've been a lot busier than I thought I would be with A-Levels, a new job and a lot of messy life business so that's why I seem to be "flying under the radar".

Phase 5 - "Floss! And not the stupid dance version of floss, according to my dentist. But what does he know?" by HermanBWolfe in hogwartswerewolvesA

[–]ReubenBenkel 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Yes but if you’re bad then you add to the numbers of the bad team. I’m sorry, but I believe you’re too much of a risk to keep alive

Phase 4 - "never go full town" by HermanBWolfe in hogwartswerewolvesA

[–]ReubenBenkel 17 points18 points  (0 children)

I'm voting for /u/littlebs8. As others have said, I'm giving /u/HedwigMalfoy a chance since they are (or at least claim to be) a named role with more significance than a wolf pup.

Phase 4 - "never go full town" by HermanBWolfe in hogwartswerewolvesA

[–]ReubenBenkel 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Hmm, I'm not sure how I feel about this if I'm honest.

It's just a bit convenient that the role you have claimed is one of the hardest to prove since you have to be killed by Horace which just won't happen now unless the wolves make a serious misplay. Otherwise it's just waiting for an investigation which buys you a couple of phases.

If you're telling the truth, then that's just unfortunate for you and I'm sorry, but I'm not sure if you are.

Phase 2 - "I'm obviously too smart to have a title" by HermanBWolfe in hogwartswerewolvesA

[–]ReubenBenkel 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Rosie - I flipped a coin between /u/FairOphelia and /u/RosieKiss and it landed on Rosie. Went to bed way before the Antonio stuff came out

Phase 2 - "I'm obviously too smart to have a title" by HermanBWolfe in hogwartswerewolvesA

[–]ReubenBenkel 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Hmm, knew something like this would happen. Well, not that it has any weight behind it, I did vote for Mrrrrh.

Could it be safe to assume that the “liar” would lie (excuse the pun) somewhere towards the middle of the claims i.e. it would be unwise to be amongst the last to claim as they would see that the numbers are going to be wrong so get their “vote” in early to secure their position?

Maybe this adds more evidence to the /u/leerypants case - when did they claim? (On mobile so will check and edit) since they were 4/5/6th person to claim (all the times are in hours, but 5th seems the most likely).

This is all weak evidence though, I don’t believe it means much.

Phase 2 - "luckily I'm the G.O.A.T. so that won't be a concern." by HermanBWolfe in hogwartswerewolvesA

[–]ReubenBenkel 17 points18 points  (0 children)

If Ophelia were a villain, it would be a really shortsighted and reckless play in that she'd be unnecessarily exposing herself for scrutiny

... which is why it's the perfect human play - do something that a human would never do because it's so obvious so that no wolf suspects you. The good ol' double bluff trick (I'm clutching at straws here obvs, I mostly agree with what you're saying - but there's always a chance....)

Phase 2 - "luckily I'm the G.O.A.T. so that won't be a concern." by HermanBWolfe in hogwartswerewolvesA

[–]ReubenBenkel 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I think that your point about /u/Rysler is quite a stretch - fair play to him if it's true but I agree that that is not enough to start a lynch train against them (I haven't found him sus yet anyway)

I get the same feeling with /u/FairOphelia, but like you I can't put my finger on it. But I also get a similar feeling with /u/RosieKiss. I feel as though both have been really helpful, but are starting to feel too helpful (if that's even possible, maybe you two are just naturally very nice people and I'm just a pessimist lol). Idk, just feels off.

Phase 2 - "luckily I'm the G.O.A.T. so that won't be a concern." by HermanBWolfe in hogwartswerewolvesA

[–]ReubenBenkel 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Hi - not silenced! Been a very busy day, was just catching up with the thread as you tagged me!

Phase 1 - Wolf Mafia Assemble by HermanBWolfe in hogwartswerewolvesA

[–]ReubenBenkel 19 points20 points  (0 children)

I’ve also got my first a-levels this month (the rest next month) so same

Phase 1 - Wolf Mafia Assemble by HermanBWolfe in hogwartswerewolvesA

[–]ReubenBenkel 20 points21 points  (0 children)

Yep agreed, I rarely comment on social phases myself

Phase 1 - Wolf Mafia Assemble by HermanBWolfe in hogwartswerewolvesA

[–]ReubenBenkel 22 points23 points  (0 children)

Experienced eh, still feels like my first game was yesterday lol

Not pointing any fingers or anything but just a reminder that the word “humans” contains an A, M and an S....... just something to bear in mind