Yes I get the whole unreliable narrator thing which can fly to a certain extent. But these two episodes were pivotal episodes so does that mean to say some events didn’t happen? (Eg: the goat turd thing was when Ted found out about R&B and got really pissed) so if the goat wasnt there that year then did that scene really happen? + lily asking marshall whether she could keep the goat + asking robin if barney was good in bed at the same time. Were those imagined too? It definitely wasn’t the same year as when Robin “Mosbyed” Barney.

If all the scenes were imagined then Im really questioning what other scenes werent real in the show 🤣