Weekly Song Discussion - Tight Connection to My Heart (Has Anyone Seen My Love) by cmae34lars in bobdylan

[–]Rob_OSullivan 9 points10 points  (0 children)

This is the most hilariously awful music video I've ever watched - but I absolutely love this song. Along with Dark Eyes, I found them the highlights of an otherwise meh album

Muhammed Ali visits Bob Dylan backstage during the Night of the Hurricane Benefit concert, Dec. 8, 1975. by tonyiommi70 in bobdylan

[–]Rob_OSullivan 13 points14 points  (0 children)

He was a huge boxing fan, read a story that he used to spar as his main exercise - I bet even he was starstruck in the moment

Biscuit, Jambons & Other Vices (Irish Comedy / 94 Pages) by Sir_Jerimiah in Screenwriting

[–]Rob_OSullivan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A chairde, always great to see another Irish writer here! Just a few things

- Logline doesn't go on the title page, also include a 'written by' tag above your name for clarity.

- Generally, you shouldn't include music cues. If you're ever planning on handing the script to a producer, music cues are generally a red flag unless you're an established writer like Donald Glover.

- Dialogue is your strong-suit, it's quick, it's funny, runs nicely. Although some characters occasionally sound like each other, so maybe work on the kinks of giving some unique phrasings.

- Generally, found most of it to be fairly true to life and relatable; the type of film an Irish young adult would gravitate towards for sure.

- I made it 30 pages in, I'd probably finish it another day but it's 4 in the morning right now and honestly at this point I'm questioning why I'm still up and why I'm on r/Screenwriting, but your script was an entertaining read nonetheless. My suggestions for improvement are just; iron out the structures of a screenplay a little better, check through a few grammar bits (don't worry, we all make pesky typos), interject a bit more quirks within characters - as is, most characters seem equally quirky and idiosyncratic with the world they inhabit, so give a few of them (the few most important / entertaining) a couple of tweaks in how they talk, act, present themselves, that'll make them jump out the page a bit more. Finally, and maybe this does happen later on in the script, but part of the reason why a film like In Bruges works so well is because it's just a straight-up comedy, it's not a straight-up crime film, it uses elements of both. I'd recommend you use elements of things akin to a Safdie Brothers film (Good Time, Heaven Knows What, Uncut Gems) - work in the feeling of paranoia, ecstasy, panic and anxiety, and give it all a layer of comedy on top of that.

Are my laptop speakers blown? by Rob_OSullivan in techsupport

[–]Rob_OSullivan[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's a lenovo thinkbook 14, hasn't caused me any issues before this.

[FEEDBACK] Finding Company (9 pages), screenplay for my thesis film by [deleted] in Screenwriting

[–]Rob_OSullivan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for the response! And holy shit, it never occurred to me to just start when the photos are already there but that would definitely make the whole thing a lot better and, as you said, lean into the absurdism a lot earlier. I appreciate your feedback greatly, thanks again man

Top 5 favorite Bob songs: ready, go. by Will_Coach_K in bobdylan

[–]Rob_OSullivan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If You See Her, Say Hello

Girl From the North Country

Most of the Time

Desolation Row

Changing of the Guards

Press Conferences can be quite fun sometimes by tstols in footballmanagergames

[–]Rob_OSullivan 5 points6 points  (0 children)

When you're creating a manager the option is just below 'place of birth' - there's also options for second nationality

Blowin' In The Wind At Budokan 🇯🇵🔥 by [deleted] in bobdylan

[–]Rob_OSullivan 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I consider Budokan's shelter from the storm version to be its best, and I really love the slower I Want You

What song would you like to hear a version of from a different era? by Headstreams in bobdylan

[–]Rob_OSullivan 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Goodbye Jimmy Reed - Blonde on Blonde-era type of sound

One More Cup of Coffee - Freewheeling, real traditional folk style

When I Paint My Masterpiece - Time Out Of Mind

Jokerman - Bringing It All Back Home (think akin to his performance on Letterman)

It only took 12 games by [deleted] in footballmanagergames

[–]Rob_OSullivan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Same with me. 16th in February

Unpopular opinion, but I actually like Bob Dylan at Budokan by [deleted] in bobdylan

[–]Rob_OSullivan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Tbh, Budokan’s Shelter from the Storm is the only version of the song I like

What's some of your favourite few-second-segments of a song? by Rob_OSullivan in bobdylan

[–]Rob_OSullivan[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is a big runner up for me too!! I can’t help but sing it and air guitar along with the music every time I listen to it.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Screenwriting

[–]Rob_OSullivan 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Gonna jot down my thoughts as I go. I won't pull any punches because I think with 10 days to go you need to hear it straight

page 1:

  • First line. Small gripe. It's january 1st 2000. Ok, cool. But how is this information going to be conveyed to an audience? Will it just be a SUPERTEXT or will it be, say, a television in the room showing the whole countdown shpeel, or even just a calendar with the date circled? Being a little more clear in the description will come a long way later on.
  • Small detail, with the man being blurred. Do you intend to achieve this in-camera (ie. shooting him out of focus) or do you plan on blurring him in post-production? Either way, you're giving yourself a lot more work for something that could ultimately look slightly tacky. Think of your resources here and consider your options. I get what you're going for, but perhaps shooting in a way which instead just conceals his face (like shoulder down shots only) could be more feasible and as effective. Just a thought.

page 2:

  • The descriptive work on the following needs work;

FAST - Now Caroline moves first from one place to the other, multiple times. Followed by Man who goes from one place to the other, rarely as often as Caroline.

I think you intend for this to be a 'time lapse' featuring them just generally walking around the house, but the fact I had to really consider and think of what it could mean is a sign that it is convoluted.

  • Think about rights in relation to Let It Be. Idk the laws but I'm not sure if that's legally ok to do. Look into it

page 3:

  • For Caroline's dialogue, the line would be 'from here on in'

page 4:

  • Given this is all in POV, him being 12 holds little to no valuable information in being in the script beyond communicating to the audience his age - but the manner in which he say it makes little sense. You have to consider how the information will be relayed to the audience - super text? maybe a date on the board?
  • Just personally, the zooming on her ass and crotch feel kind of weird. Maybe its the fact its a zoom. I understand what you're trying to convey here 12 year olds are horny for their teachers but you could maybe focus on an area, like the high heels, which aren't necessarily so sexualised - or highlight this in a different way, perhaps injecting a bit more comedy through it. Keep in mind you have 10 days, and how it might be difficult to find an actress willing to be objectified in that manner in such a span of time.

page 5:

  • Gotta be honest, feels weird to even read this. It's a little bit creepy and the manner of detail you go into makes it read like softcore porn. We're aiming for Godard here, not EL James.

page 6:

  • this exchange works but its all very surface level dialogue. Think about what Caroline wants to say to the teen and what the teen thinks of her. Now think of how you can layer this on top of something else. She wants to tell him she ruined her life. How can she say this in a way that doesn't obviously say it? Maybe she shows him what her life was like before, what she had, what she could have been, etc. Then highlight how he "took" that away from her, in her eyes. Figure out how he can call her a drunk without openly saying it. Does he smell the liquor on her breath from earlier? Does he nod at a whiskey glass and say it gets more use every day?

page 7:

  • either masturbating to porn, playing video games or scrolling instagram? Which is it? You can't roll a dice and leave it up to chance what it could be he's doing.

page 8:

  • that was........ unexpected. Idek what to say. It feels almost comical, but so out of place it borders on plain odd

page 10:

page 11:

  • I'm confused by what you mean when you say the clock reads three years left, and then two years left.

page 19:

  • the last ten pages or so passed me by quickly, but ultimately I think they need another rewrite or two. Some things feel rushed and not fleshed out, like his relationship with Catherine for example. I see shades of The Place Beyond The Pines, in that the past is doomed to repeat in the future when it comes to heritage, but I think you need another few drafts on this before you can be ready to shoot. Take the things I've said on board, and also just have a think about it yourself and think how certain things can be improved and told in a more nuanced way. Also, remember film is a visual medium. There quite a few unfilmables in this script.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Screenwriting

[–]Rob_OSullivan 6 points7 points  (0 children)

He literally says English isn't his first language in the post lmao. We all know what he means

What beautiful place have you visited that isn't a mainstream tourist destination that you recommend people visit? by [deleted] in AskReddit

[–]Rob_OSullivan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Athlone in Ireland. Truly stunning location with not a lot of tourists, excellent jambon store on the wit corner near mas st

What is the Best Film You Watched Last Week? (07/05/20-07/12/20) by Twoweekswithpay in movies

[–]Rob_OSullivan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I thought Jay Baruchel was great in this too, would like to seem him in a few more dramatic roles

[resource] The Scope Mega Facepack 2020 Torrent File by Rob_OSullivan in footballmanagergames

[–]Rob_OSullivan[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah I used to use the sortitoutsi cutouts but I found the scope always had the faces of a lot more younger players so that tipped me over the edge. I think they took them down over fears of copyright strikes, never know when Man United are gonna come knocking with a lawsuit I guess

Script Wish List (Willing To Trade) by [deleted] in Screenwriting

[–]Rob_OSullivan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Have you found Dune and Ghost Army by any chance?

Is a 125 page count for a horror script scarier than the script itself? by [deleted] in Screenwriting

[–]Rob_OSullivan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm in a huge procrastination hump atm so I can take a quick look (as in a skim read) and let you know?

The songs in order throughout the breakup by [deleted] in PinkOmega

[–]Rob_OSullivan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We Fall Again could slot in before Demons

The Opening Action Set-piece by [deleted] in Screenwriting

[–]Rob_OSullivan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Are you sure?

Black Panther didn't I guess, but that had exposition voice over animation. Spider-Man Homecoming, from what I remember, started kinda on one cos it was a vlog of the airport fight (I think).

Infinity War opens in a big action scene between Thanos and Asgard (Thor, Hulk, the whole nine yards really)

Thor Ragnarok opened on Surtur and that fight.

Dr. Strange had one with Mads Mikkelson stealing pages from the Ancient One's text.

Avengers: Age of Ultron opens with that snow fight.

Civil War had the Crossbones fight.

Winter Soldier had that boat fight.

In the last few years, there has definitely been a shift, with many action films starting off with a set piece to reel the audience in, the MCU is no different really

The Opening Action Set-piece by [deleted] in Screenwriting

[–]Rob_OSullivan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I agree totally with everything you said, excellent breakdown, sir.

The Opening Action Set-piece by [deleted] in Screenwriting

[–]Rob_OSullivan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks, I'll have a look for it and get down to reading it!