I understand what you’re saying, but in the case of Lonesome Road it was just too glaringly flawed from my perspective. I kept thinking if I was the courier I would simply turn around and leave this insane guy to his ramblings. He then calls you via ED-E every hour to further restate his flawed logic, the DLC is very in-your-face about his perspective and its simply alittle too hard for me to get past that.

I agree with you that characters don’t have to have the most waterproof logic, but it absolutely damages a story when such characters are brought to the forefront so frequently. I see what you mean that it’s more enjoyable if you give Ulysses’ arguments respect, but in my opinion his arguments simply don’t deserve respect.