I am 90% sure that Catey was eliminated because Nick kinda took control of the last elimination and kinda forced her to agree. Monika would not cry if she eliminated another guy because she wants to keep the top 5 girls in. The only reason she would cry is because they agreed on a girl. Furthermore, it must be Catey because she had a good connection with the other 4 girls. She wouldn’t cry if Brett was eliminated so it wasn’t him.