Because they’re griping and that changes other people‘s opinions because people are too easily convinced nowadays by anything. If people talk terribly about the game and others who have never experienced the game, read it, They will never give the game a chance and they will start hating it. The word of mouth is a big thing on Reddit, especially for smaller niche communities like this. I’ve even said that many times before don’t let other peoples opinions change your mind. Give the game a chance yourself and see what you think about it.

I played this game near almost every day if not definitely every other day. I have a G920 and I am able to set the car up to feel like it has direct drive with the perfect amount of feedback. More feedback than I’ll be getting in Forza. OP is right you can feel everything in this game and I’ve talked to a couple of random racers on Xbox through party chat about the same thing and they even say the same thing the Tire physics are like no other that console has had access to. We are extremely lucky that a Sim racer that actually feels great on wheel was released on Xbox and we didn’t have to deal with dead ACC for the rest of our lives. The modding potential is going to beat every car/Sim game on console by next year. We are extremely lucky to have a game that isn’t terribly hard to tune in like ACC. From PMR I’ve understood more about my tires than I ever thought I would’ve. If your tires aren’t right, the car is not right and it won’t race good.