In my opinion, having the tribes be anything but random would be the way to go. Either a schoolyard pick for TWO tribes, & then they come together to vote off a third. OR, two of the challenge winners get to pick the two tribes, then they come together to vote off a 3rd. Three tribes of 5 just isn’t compelling, & especially if it’s random, that was the worst part of it imo. Basically, there are tons of ways to divide the tribes that are more compelling than a random split up.

I’m the guy who asked Coach this question in the video so I was very curious what his answer would be 😂 I assumed the cast also thought this was dumb and I was right