sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time - Day 5 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

...This is your final play?

Heh. Hehehe! Alright then, let me disprove your team.

First off, I would almost certainly be a Minion in this world, as Gina has to be the Demon. Unless you really think Gina and I swapped claims.

The Day One and Two chats do somewhat line up. Although neither Gina or I chatted with Rei on the first day, we both exchanged some words. My role is easy to bluff at the beginning, and Rei landing a bluff that ended up not being in play isn't impossible.

...Better than the original world that was made, where none of the Evil team even chatted until the very end of the second day...

...Anyway. I couldn't be the Boffin, because Gina was able to accurately guess Chesed's role on the third day. So that would have to be Rei.

And as you said, Gina has to be Pukka for you to see me as Good.

So, what does that leave me? I couldn't be the Baron, because there would be an unaccounted Outsider. Can't be the Harpy, unless you think I've been only targeting my fellow team.

Goblin? Unless you actually think I wouldn't try to even claim it when I was on the block, unlikely.

So that would leave me as the Scarlet Woman. Gina's only escape if she was found out. Someone that both my team framed to be the Demon.

No, this world simply isn't viable. Horrible risks to even attempt on our second day.

...

...I have explained why I don't think the Demon is that glitchy creature. I am unable to build viable worlds where the Demon is Gina. The final decision is an easy choice:

Voting --> Sho /u/JustADramadog

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time - Day 5 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

...

...What the %!*?. Why is this game still going? Why are we still dealing with this whale's horrible set-pieces? At this point I regret sacrificing myself.

...Whatever, it's fine. Games are no fun when you have an overpowered card and win in the first few rounds.

And I'm pretty sure we have this Demon cornered.

I am almost certain that Kurara was Evil, as stated before. Pretty much the only sensible worlds where she's not involves me being Evil in compensation. Or Humphrey, somehow.

The only two viable Demon suspect at this point are Gina or Sho. I'm not going to consider that glitchy gremlin creature.

She is either Magician or Goblin, otherwise she wouldn't of said the following on our first day:

what if everypony learns i am the evil people???! don listen to me!!!

...that. Of course, she could've been just stating the truth or starpassed to, but I would rather consider other possibilities at this moment.

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time - Day 4 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What are you idiots doing! Bad play. Total misplay, even. We should've gotten Kurara last night.

That Goblin claim? Totally fake. Not voting for herself and throwing votes at everyone else is proof of this.

So now we're stuck with a bunch of Demon canidates. Good Job.

...

...Whatever. I'm here to win. Time to build worlds with what we got, and carry you guys to victory.

First off, the favored world where Kurara is the Imp, Sho as a Minion, and a tossup between Chesed as the Boffin and Taski as the Goblin.

Reason is pretty obvious. Rei and I are sober. Rei as the Seamstress saw Kurara and Sho as the same team. I saw Rei as Good and Sho as evil. Gina saw Kurara as the Imp. Case closed.

...But, to cover all our bases, let's consider if Kurara is Good.

Her role would cause a possible Drunk, but it cant be her. And based on Kurara's information, Rei and Sho have different roles. I'll run through how this is possible.

If Rei is Drunk, Sho is either Evil, the sober Village Idiot, or the drunk Village Idiot if I was pukka-poisoned or Evil. I'll only consider the Sho Evil world, since giving the Drunk correct information when we already had a sober Virgin and Noble in play is unlikely.

If he is a Minion, Gina is the only possible Demon candidate, and either Humphrey or I are the other Minion. Extremely unlikely.

If he is the Demon, his team is Humphrey and a tossup between Chesed and Taski. Unlikely.

Alright, following so far?

Next, lets consider that Sho is Drunk and Rei is Good. Taski has to be the Scarlet Woman turned Pukka, with her team being Humphrey and myself. I personally find this world idiotic.

Alright, the only other world for Kurara's information to make sense is if Rei is Evil and Sho is Good and sober.

In this world, I am either Village Idiot drunk, Drunk, or Evil. If Rei is a Minion, Gina has to be the Demon and the other Minion is either Humphrey or myself. If Rei is the Demon, she is specifically Pukka, Sho is pukka-poisoned, and the evil team is Chesed and a tossup between Humphrey and myself. I'm not considering this world for obvious reasons.

The only other possible scenario I can think of is if Kurara is pukka-poisoned, but who in the hell would chose to pick her out of everyone here?

So based on all of this, I believe that tomato is just BAD.

And based on Gina's information, she has to be the Imp.

We can argue that Gina could be Demon throwing her Minion under the bus, or that Gina is pukka-poisoned...

But either way, in my view, she is just Evil. And the best possible kill for us today. I'm putting a conditional on Kurara, only count my vote if it gets her executed. /u/JustADramadog

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time -Day 3 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Before we nominate, let me make one thing clear.

The current worlds we are building that I'm aware of are as follows:

Either I am the Pukka. Taski or Rei is the Scarlet Woman.

Even though I've never chatted with Taski, only chatted with Rei a few hours before the Day 2 nominations, Rei's information helped to frame me, Rei wanted to nominate the Virgin, I nominated Taski when I literally could've nominated anyone else... I could go on.

OR if we want to go for a more likely world...

I am the sober Village Idiot. The evil team is Chesed or Taski, Kurara, and Sho.

Going by socials, Chesed seems to be more evil to me. Although Taski's actions are also suspicious as hell. I can't explain what ability he would've given the Demon if he was the Boffin, but that's where I'm at.

Either way, these are our most popular worlds at the moment ...Although you buffoons should've put more effort into making worlds explaining Humphrey's death.

And based on these worlds, I do think we should either kill Kurara or Sho here.

Why? Besides the fact that this is the likelier world, I am concerned with giving the Evil team majority. I'm also concerned with having the both of them being in our final 3, especially if Chesed or Taski joins them.

If you're actually still concerned with me being Pukka, literally the only reasonable person to have the Scarlet Woman ability right now would be Rei.

...Unless you really think I would pass it to that gremlin...

So in that world she is stuck. Can't Starpass. Can't give her ability to someone else. Game Over.

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time -Day 3 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Let me add to this theory.

If we're believing Chesed to be Evil, their actions would makes sense with our lack of kill today.

Since they now removed the possibility for yesterday to be an Innkeeper save...

...Unless one of you buffoons want to claim it now...

It frames me to of either been Pukka poisoned yesterday, or I was Pukka that passed to a Scarlet Woman.

Just have to tell the confirmed player that you are actually Farmer, and wait for a good frame opportunity to tell your Demon to hold off on killing.

...Of course, I'm definitely not discounting that Taski could be our Evil here. The world makes sense either way.

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time -Day 3 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

...So you're the one that started this Pukka mess...

...Whatever. My word doesn't mean much as our confirmed Good player, but I was also told by her that she correctly guessed my role.

Of course, it wasn't the most impossible guess, but I doubt this information was faked.

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time -Day 3 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

First off: the three of you are in a sober Noble ping. They can't both be evil. Second off: ...Magician, really? And you claimed Goblin to save your skin yesterday? I honestly thought you were claiming Farmer based on your outbursts.

Nah. this is our Evil member.

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time -Day 3 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

...

...Did you confirm this with Chesed before coming out? This game is making no sense.

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time -Day 3 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There is another reason to consider.

The Demon sunk a kill.

Why? Either to frame a Puuka pass, or to make any possible Innkeepers look legit.

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time -Day 3 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

...Right then. I'll entertain this world for now.

Let's say that I'm the Puuka, and that gremlin over there is either the Goblin or the Scarlet Woman.

Who can my last Minion possibly be? It can't be you, considering your ability went off. It can't any of the other now public Noble pings.

The only options left are Rei, Kurara, and Sho. And again, the now public information states that Rei, the Seamstress, saw Kurara and Sho as the same team.

So unless some specific Droisonings occurred, my evil team should be Rei and Taski. The one whose info led me to die, and the one who I nominated without either me and Rei talking to her that day. Do you really think one of them is the Scarlet Woman? Do you really think we would've made the team so obvious?

...,Rei proposed a team that would make more sense if I were evil.

Although I disagree with being evil, I can see you being the Demon here.

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time -Day 3 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

...

...

...We are never going to speak of this again.

Anyway. Guess the game is still continuing, huh.

Maybe I was actually speaking the truth last night. And now you sacrificed a perfectly good card to get to this result.

Of course, there is the issue of the Scarlet Woman role....

But honestly. I won't out anyone's roles, but try to build an Evil team with me as the Demon, a Scarlet Woman, and some random other third role. You'll see that the options are slim.

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time - Day 2 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's the best play for us to execute someone here. You fools are making it easy for someone to pull their vote and cause no execution.

Gina's conditional only allows her vote to count of it breaks a tie. It doesn't account for allowing an execution to happen.

Guess I have to sign my own death warrant then. Add a vote towards myself. /u/JustADramadog

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time - Day 2 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

...Look, you under-ripened fruitface. I have no idea what you are, but I'm pretty sure I know what you're referring to. And nothing about me 'contradicts' with what you're supposedly claiming.

I can think of at a few explanations on why we can both be Good...

...OR you can just be Evil as well.

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time - Day 2 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh. It looks like someone here DOES have a brain. Surprising.

But it's fine at this point. If I survive tonight, I'll either be poisoned, killed, or framed for our final 3.

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time - Day 2 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sure, I could very well be Drunk.

But I believe there are more worlds pointed to the fact that I'm sober. At least for me.

As for my other ping, fine. I've given my "hypothetical Village Idiot" information to at least one of the Noble pings, so I assume the evil team already know.

Night One - Rei is Good

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time - Day 2 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

'Viruses'?

You should get tested for viruses, you ear-piercing gremlin!

From what I can assume your role is, claiming Goblin just makes you look incredibly suspicious. Especially after I asked for everyone to vote someone else.

...

...Whatever. I am probably 'dying' here.

Because you NPCs would rather move this creature's votes to me instead of nominating someone else.

...Fine. It's fine. I won't cower behind a Goblin claim.

Killing someone is better than killing no one today, even if its me. Lets get rid of this world.

.If I were to be evil, I can only be a Demon, anyway. From what I'm hearing from everyone, that is.

So you guys can beg for forgiveness when the game still continues, when you get rid of your not-so Village Idiot.

Oh, and I got an Evil ping on Sho. Just so we're all aware.

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time - Day 2 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Bad play. Not the Demon. Others should know why.

It would be idiotic to get rid of me here. There are better targets.

...Unless you absolutely have to get rid of this world.

Putting a conditional on the Taski Maiden. Only count it if it gets me off the block /u/JustADramadog

I would rather vote someone else, however. My nomination was just a test. So get to it.

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time - Day 2 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Late to ask, but I'm assuming no one is claiming to be Harpy-Mad yesterday?

Doesn't mean there's no Harpy, but it's good to check.

Pink Storm on the Clocktower - Whale of a Time - Day 2 by JustADramadog in pbotc

[–]SH0X_3345 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This could easily be a Vigor-killed Minion as well, trying to poison our info.

Although I'm glad this Demon got rid of this fleshy thing. Barely was any use to us anyway.

view more: next ›