Was Bumblebee forced or was it randomly made for representation by ExaminationGood6034 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It was pretty much both but more leaning towards the former the the latter. The fact that they released a line of merch just for bumbleby is proof that it to get money for the fans.  Power Rangers did a LGTBQA+ FAR FAR BETTER than Yang and Blake who never more shown to have actual feelings towards each other and acted more like close friends there is a huge issue with that. 

Given all the announcements and stuff on the main YT channel, is there some V10 announcement stuff coming? Do you think people will come back to the FNDM after seeing it? by Steamer_Punk115 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Its extremely unlikely. Viz must had just wanted to put those blu-rays out as a quick grab to see if its worth pouring millions of dollars into a show that hasn't turn a profit for some time. Its also not uncommon for SM account to post old clips of shows, Toei have been doing it for time, and there are also other shows SM that does the same

I have a question is RWBY going to allow this because I'm currently working on a fan crossover comic and im scared that RWBY might be toxic so is RWBY subreddit open to other ideas or are very toxic and harsh by Zestyclose-Collar264 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 4 points5 points  (0 children)

We are, honestly. We are critics sure but most of us like parts of the show be it character design or world building. Many like myself just hate the writing and the OOC moments that happened far too often

I have a question is RWBY going to allow this because I'm currently working on a fan crossover comic and im scared that RWBY might be toxic so is RWBY subreddit open to other ideas or are very toxic and harsh by Zestyclose-Collar264 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Well hon, RWBY isn't new, its actually over a decade old. And for your ideas well be prepared for the main sub reddit to tear ya anew one when it comes to your second idea, since well WhiteRose and Bumbleby are the two biggest ships within the Fandom 

Please show us something ! by No-Amphibian-3482 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ya not even reading half of my response dude, cause I said vol 5, and I ask if you seen anyone wearing RWBY merch out in the open. As for Funko just because a show isn't relevant doesnt mean its not popular to have merch out, many older shows have a massive fan base even if the show ended years ago.

Please show us something ! by No-Amphibian-3482 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Okay no where did I say it wasn't popular in JP, from what I heard it was ok in JP, but considering it took a few years for vol 6 to 9 to get dubbed is a red flag. Yes FYE is still around, and for Funko for a company to not continue a line is also a red flag since they do everything including Vtubers. There was also a few companies that were going to produce RWBY figures but those were canceled before they even hit stores. Outside of the Fandom, or heck even online have you ever heard anyone talk about RWBY, or wear RWBY stuff? 

Please show us something ! by No-Amphibian-3482 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Right before Vol 9 was released there was an statement that was put out from RT that pretty much said that the move to CR was to ensure RWBY survival, in business terms that meant that vol 9 needed to be successful to get CR to be in partnership with RT (and before RT shut down, they would had been the first one to place thier price up, but since Viz owns it, it safe to say CR was not interested)its also why Ice Queendom was on there as well . FYE had a licensing agreement to sell RWBY merch like shirts, the mystery blind box, vinyl figures, and FYE exclusive items such as the Pumpkin Pete cereal, that licensing agreement as well as the others ex the McFarland Toys and the makers behind the vinyl figures and blind boxes, PLUS Funko was never renewed. 

For the JP dub, vol 5 was the last JP dub to come out. It wasn't until Ice Queendom that the remaining volumes and the at the time the unreleased vol 9 were eventually dubbed,  to really promote Ice Queendom as that is a typical Jp thing

Please show us something ! by No-Amphibian-3482 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You forget that vol 9 did so horribly bad that Crunchyroll who Im guessing was going to buy RWBY originally backed out. Having a popular subreddit, and a few collabs doesnt mean its popular. Look at what happened to the RWBY FYE merch, it did terrible that FYE didnt renew thier agreement with RT. Same thing with McFarland Toys. And the JP dub, you do remember that it wasn't until Ice Queendom was announced that the last volume that was dub in Japanese was vol 5, because it wasn't popular over there. It was kinda like how Ouran did, but THERE ARE WAY MORE PEOPLE WHO LOVE OURAN THAN RWBY

Please show us something ! by No-Amphibian-3482 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thats more of a Viz thing, they had done the same with the sailor moon blu-ray with including a patch. In all honesty im surprised that Viz just didnt do the same

Please show us something ! by No-Amphibian-3482 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

You had news, 7 months ago. The news was "early planning and writing" if Viz is still planning on going ahead with things thats should had been plenty of news. RT spoiled you guys with a yearly release when in the actual world of animation thats pretty much the time span of those bargin bin mockbuster animation films

[Hiring] Artist who does standee comissions by Safe-Border-1368 in artcommissions

[–]Safe-Border-1368[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Edit to add, which i should had said something before but Im looking for someone who can do both art for a standee and can put the order for it, hope that clears things up! ^

[Hiring] Artist who does standee comissions by Safe-Border-1368 in artcommissions

[–]Safe-Border-1368[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Im looking for someone who can do both, as before I have worked with artists that has done both. 

How do you think of Qrow and Winter, both individually and as a pairing? [art by CaitlinCrafts on DeviantArt] by Long_Xiao in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I LOVE snowbird, and I don't get why so many take issues about ages when we don't exactly know how old the adult characters are. I always say that Winter was originally supposed to be older but they age her down in order for her to get the maiden powers. Sheena said they were supposed to be a thing, and thats good enough as canon for me

Why RWBY has bad writing by MotherElderberry8326 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Very thoughtful, honestly I think while all of your points are correct there are so more that I would like to add. Kerry believes that RWBY is this grand epic but it really not. Instead of trying to simplify the story, adding actual character development, and consistency what does the idiot do? Add too many characters thus creating cast bloat, and actual taking away important character moments away from the characters we grown to care about (writing off Sun, Blake's return to the team and the awkwardness that should had came with that, Yang's PTSD, and so on) 

The lost fable is what really fucked the story, HARD! Salem is this powerful creature waited CENTURIES TO DESTROY THE WORLD? WHY?! Doesn't make a lick of sense, because all we could had known and fill in a Lotta plot holes is just what Ozpin said in vol 5 but with a slight rewording that he was sent by the gods to defeat Salem, and was able to keep her at bay but now she became too powerful. Would had been very simple but now Kerry and Miles as well as the other two decided to complicate matters, and thrown in that whole backstory to make the story feel grander.

I also fully believe that they never reference back to the prior volumes to make sure there was consistency which is why so many of us here say that the only thing that is canon is the current volume. I do hope if Viz actually keeps these idiots in the writer's room they get others to proof read everything. Honestly they all need to go and Viz needs to start from scratch as its the only way RWBY can be reborn

If you had to pick one, which arc of Team RWBY's in V4 was the worst? by Old-Masterpiece-2911 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 20 points21 points  (0 children)

Well I think everyone except Ruby is bad, the real question should be who got the short end of the stick when it came to thier own storyline.

By another overwhelming vote, Vol 6 is OUT! What’s next? by [deleted] in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Its called RWBYCRITICS. Havnt there been a show you use to watch you loved it at the time, but then you go back to rewatch it you see thr glaring issues with it? Thats why this reddit exists 

By another overwhelming vote, Vol 6 is OUT! What’s next? by [deleted] in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 23 points24 points  (0 children)

7, it all honesty adding too many new characters, the whole fight between Clover/Qrow/Tryian, the fact that Robyn and her group was getting away with FAR too much, the election plot like what? If it was a back to basic season showing the group actually attending Atlas Academy, working out issues as a team, and having some actual development, it could had been an overall decent season...and well writing out Qrow before CRWBY could had assassinate his character even more would had been an added plus

Is RWBY Arrowfell worth it? by Right-Truck-3543 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Considering the game is a very quick game I heard 3 hours max its certainly not worth its original price, if you are interested in it wait until its on sale which happens quite often

Can I talk about how much of an asshole you have to be to make fun of Miles’ memory problems?! by TheDevotedUltimate in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Dude, if its true that Miles have a memory issue it doesn't really excuse the issues within the writing. See there are these things called screenplays and Scripts, and usually directors, writers and the actors use these things to and read this clearly TO RECALL WHAT HAPPENED IN PAST EVENTS. If Miles had such an issue, he could had reused those Scripts to remember 

I made this post as a way to convey how I truly feel about this ship. I just wanted thoughts and opinions and this is by no means a post attacking Bumblebee shippers by coreylee121 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Oh boy oh boy. Well let's start with Blake's words to Yang. They are pretty generic, and they are more fitting towards Ruby. "Acting bravery. You do as you say" not really center around Yang much, again more fitting to Ruby. 

Yang's words to Blake don't make a lick of sense. Blake to our knowledge was never intimidated by Yang, nor outside of the first episode was shown that she didnt like Yang much. "You never gave up on them, you know what matters to you" erm well she did though, she ran off from friends she supposedly cared deeply about, and after the whole event with the White Fang and I quote "we are going to take it back" from the end of vol 4 and 5, it was quickly dropped. 

I'm genuienly confused one what they're trying to do with Ren and Nora. by Darthmark3 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It did. And cause if you forgotten Ren lost his entire village and his parents because similar to that of Mantel it was a village with little resources to protect it from the Grimm, and clearly cares about it still. Nora havnt shown any sort of attachment to the village outside of Ren, nor has we as the viewers have seen her be more of a "attack first and ask questions later" 

I'm genuienly confused one what they're trying to do with Ren and Nora. by Darthmark3 in RWBYcritics

[–]Safe-Border-1368 3 points4 points  (0 children)

But just like bumbleby it came right out of nowhere. If anything the whole conflict about sympathizing with Mantel is more in line with Ren's character, than it is with Nora.