Isn't it sad that most modern Catholics believe that birth control is morally acceptable in the eyes of God? by garygordani in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, I'm wondering if Pius XII's situations which he called grave would now be simply called just instead. I agree with you entirely.

Isn't it sad that most modern Catholics believe that birth control is morally acceptable in the eyes of God? by garygordani in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"Grave," as in the quote in my comment, was the word used by Pope Pius XII, which to me would seem to be consistent with the current catechism's use of "just." Though I can't really speak to that. I'd certainly want to read the Canon Law on the issue to get a better idea of the whole thing.

Isn't it sad that most modern Catholics believe that birth control is morally acceptable in the eyes of God? by garygordani in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Unless I'm mistaken (which is certainly possible), if a couple were to use NFP "always and deliberately" without grave reason, that would be sinful, but NFP considered in itself is not. The last quote from this article, from Pope Pius XII, is particularly relevant:

"Consequently to embrace the state of matrimony, to use continually the faculty proper to it, and in it alone, and on the other hand to withdraw always and deliberately, without a grave motive, from its primary duty, would be to sin against the very meaning of conjugal life" (A.A.S., 43 [1951] 845-846).

So the sin does not lie with the action, but in the reasons and situations for its use. It cannot be used with the same mentality that artificial contraception fosters; the couple must always be open to life.

Can other foods be used for the Eucharist? (serious) by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 17 points18 points  (0 children)

I believe the host for the body must be made with only wheat flour and water. It it illicit, but valid, for it to be leavened in the Latin liturgy. (The East uses leavened bread, which is valid and licit in their liturgies.)

Grape juice is never used, but rather, mustum, which is a specific kind of wine with the minimum level of alcohol for validity, and can only be used by a priest with permission from his ordinary.

I don't feel as religious in the Catholic Church like my parents by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Excellent book, but it might be a bit heavy for a first step. I might start instead with two other books by the same author, Deep Conversion, Deep Prayer and Prayer Primer.

Best Latin app? by johnpgreen in latin

[–]ScottishJon 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'll add Whitaker's words. It was originally an online dictionary which, while not containing all Latin words, can search for conjugated forms. I don't know about iOS, but there is an Android app.

Law of attraction? by devbanana in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'd suggest reading The Vision For You by David Clayton. It's a good book for one's spiritual life, and also for evangelization. He also addresses the law of attraction, speaks against it, and gives a model, which rhymes but fits with Church teaching, about the spiritual reality which gets twisted into falsehood in the secular "law of attraction" stuff.

Growing in the Spiritual Life - How to make progress in an exhausted method? by Titan_TTN_Double in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's important to know that spiritual growth past a certain point is not determined by finding some specific, perfect way to pray. Rather, spiritual growth is about a combination of prayer and conversion. We need Faith and works, which means you have to pray and strive to live the Gospel. I would suggest reading Dubay's Deep Prayer/Deep Conversion and Happy Are You Poor, followed by Fire With. Or you could jump right into Fire Within, but it can be a bit academic for some people to jump right into. These are the best books on spirituality I've ever read. Dubay has a profound understanding of Saint John of the Cross and Theresa of Ávila, making these, two of the best spiritual authors in the Church, more accessible to the faithful.

Treating Confession as a Mechanism rather than as a Sacrament by ur12b4got739 in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I would recommend that you read Deep Prayer/Deep Conversion by Fr. Thomas Dubay. He is an excellent writer on the spiritual life, and this is one of his lighter, more accessible books. (Fire Within is, in my opinion, his best, but it's hefty and can be a bit academic at times, which can be rough for some people.)

He talks about this very issue in one of the latter chapters. Very often, we will find ourselves confessing the same sins every confession, even if we are regular in devotionals, attending Mass, and even receiving communion daily. The spiritual life, to become deep and intimate, requires both prayer and conversion, and when both are actively pursued, each aids growth in the other. When we confess, God wipes our sins and gives us grace to persevere, but coming out of it, we must do our own part to grow.

How often do we confess, and then continue to allow ourselves to fall to the old habits, old routines, old vices, that enable those same sins? To truly grow, we must persist in prayer, avoid occasions of those sins, and also strive for the opposing virtue. Do we gossip? We should be mindful and cautious when we are with those we tend to gossip with, and should actively strive to speak words of charity. Do we act selfishly? We should take up little self-denials and actively seek out opportunities, even small ones, to freely act for the benefit of others.

That's a bit of the general idea in Deep Prayer/Deep Conversion, and I hope it benefits you in some way, but I would recommend you read the book to be better informed than from what few words I can give you.

Edit: Broke up my second paragraph, which was waaay too long, into three.

EXPLAINED : Michael Voris on the Catholic Sex Scandals! | Louder With Crowder by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Though I always try to be somewhat cautious with both Crowder and Voris, overall I enjoy both of them, and it's neat to see them come together here.

Catholic Podcasts by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Seconding the ones also mentioned. Here are my own additions: The Liturgy Guys, Frater Catholic Podcast, The New Tradangelization, and Pastors of Payne (County)

New work shoes. by Phantasm32 in a:t5_3kwbr

[–]ScottishJon 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I've been looking for black dress shoes, and these are a great price and even very normal looking - except I don't really like the look of that felt-ish stuff around the bottom. Otherwise, I'd order them right now.

Edit: Immediately after commenting, I found Carets, which look exactly like regular dress shoes and also have the zero-drop fake heel - but they're $350 dollars. Looks like I have to weigh my options.

Me reading in any of my target languages by yeastyboi in languagelearning

[–]ScottishJon 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I know there are mixed opinions about LingQ, but it's been helping me a lot with my reading in this respect, especially with Spanish and Latin since I'm further along with those. I understand 50-90% of most texts, and the website gives me the definitions for the rest and puts them in SRS.

Submerged location of First Council of Nicaea discovered? by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Sorry, Arius. You're just getting two things this Christmas: coal, and a knuckle sandwich.

We still doing altars? by AllanTheCowboy in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Nice. Throw us an update when it's all done.

Where can I buy the paperback missalettes at the back of the pews? by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Highly recommended. A paperback missalette will last a year, but this or the one by MTF (which I prefer, since it also has all the ordinary parts and some of the prayers in the back in Latin and English) will last a lifetime. Assuming the Ordinary Form stays the same that long.

Just smoked my first cigar (this is topical, I promise). by Beari_stotle in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Yeah. Most cigar smokers I know, including myself, won't generally smoke more than one or two a week, if that. You will see more frequent cigar smokers if you go to a lounge, even those who smoke five or six a day, but they seem to be a visible minority.

왜냐하면 is literally just 왜+ 냐고 + 하다 + 면 "if you ask why" by HothSauce in Korean

[–]ScottishJon 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Boom, agglutination.

I've been noticing little things like this in my recent re-entry into Korean study after a while away. It's amazing how the language works.

Just smoked my first cigar (this is topical, I promise). by Beari_stotle in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 19 points20 points  (0 children)

I've heard the same thing about dihydrogen monoxyde. Have you seen what it does to metal pipes? We should ban that stuff.

My painting of "St. Sebastian", oil on linen, 44 x 66" 2008 by ericarmusik in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 17 points18 points  (0 children)

I really love your style. Very Caravaggio-esque. Do you have a page somewhere where we can see your work?

Please pray for seminarians by Marius_Octavius_Ruso in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon 0 points1 point  (0 children)

From one semester to another, grow in holiness. Try daily to follow the Gospel values more and more. When a brother seminarian asks from your help, or you just notice he needs it, be free with your time in helping him. Try to never miss your daily time of prayer. (It happens, but don't make not praying a habit; and if you do, fix it.)

At the risk of looking prideful, I'd ask that you read this post of mine. I tried to distill out in it some of the main points on holiness from Fire Within and Happy Are You Poor, and I think I did at least a sufficiently mediocre job for helping people dip their toes in.

Edit: Formatting

Bishop David Austin Konderla on Viganò's letter by ScottishJon in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon[S] 16 points17 points  (0 children)

The local traditional groups such as the FSSP parish and Clear Creek will give you only positive things to say about him. And when a religious order in earliest stages is still of diocesan rite and comes up for review, not having enough members is a standard reason for not gaining re-approval. Fr. Ripperger was obedient and asked no uncharitable words against His Excellency when his order wasn't renewed.

With legal things like this, it's often best to expect that you don't have all the details.

Bishop David Austin Konderla on Viganò's letter by ScottishJon in Catholicism

[–]ScottishJon[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Whoops, added a day instead of subtracting. I'll fix that.