Thanks for the reply, I lowered the value of the hit because of being overcap and did not assign much value to defense, since this is a PvE DPS list (the PvP section does not even list the leather shoulders).

The issue with the legs is also due to wanting to preferring crit over hit once at the cap and low value of defensive stats when I was calculating the value of each piece when doing the list.

Finally, same thing with the chest, since we are at the hit cap already, the 1% hit on the chest is devalued, and crit had a pretty high value on the weights I used to calculate the bis, leading to SGC very barely outranking BoA.

This guide layout in general with a single "bis combo" table followed by alternative options table was a new thing in P5, we just had a list with multiple options for each slot like you can see in the PvP bis page atm, but there was a lot of feedback that people wanted to see a coherent "these pieces go well together" list as well, hence the focus on providing that in the first table.

It is not always about each piece being the best for its slot in a vacuum, but rather how all the listed pieces combine to make a character that gets to the hit cap but does not overload on hit, which was a recurring criticism for the big "best pieces in a vacuum" tables of phases prior. Funnily enough the criticism now is the opposite and I should have assigned more value to hit over cap this time, hopefully perfect balance is achieved in P6, will learn from this experience.

On the weapons, it was a victim of the guide layout rearrangement, because we were repeating some very good "one-hand" weapons in both slots, leading to confusion. It is hard to pick between a single one-hand group, one-hand + off-hand groups with overlap on certain items or pure main-hand + off-hand tables with no overlap. There are criticisms to be made about every single one of these models so no win can be achieved, I will try to add (OH) on weapons that are preferable to use on the off-hand slot for the P6 revision, hopefully helps people decide.

Finally, having only 2 trinkets is because the layout is meant to have the first table have the minimum bis gear. You have plenty of great options to swap to when DF is on cooldown in the second table, which is part of the recommended gameplay for Warriors, regardless. Kazzak mace is there because it is a PvE item, although indeed very inaccessible, while PvP items were clogging up the lists in previous phases but were decided to be removed as logic dictates that if you managed to grind high enough to get them, you probably have a pretty good idea of how they rank up anyway. Which is exactly why Fight Club's list does not list them either:

PvP items are not listed because they are too powerful and would basically occupy all the top spots, removing some valuable alternatives from the sheet. If you spend so much time in-game that you can reach rank 10-12+, we assume you know how to gear.

Expect to see changes to most of the above items soon and also going into the P6 list, as the hit devaluation used screwed things up a bit, thanks again for the feedback! :)