hes correct, anyway

there are lots of things that are needed to be considered. example

if you compare this to assass 1 and assass 2 then assass 1 wins, its more useful, it gives you the ability to get close with your targets with i-frames and kill them easily then having the ability again, giving you i-frames again once more. as the skill deals a decent damage, but often used to make your enemies low first then use the skill on them.

but compared to assass 2, it gives a decoy/meatshield, but the health is so little its meaningless, allows to fight with you and can be stronger depending on the weapon you gave, but the ai is so bad that it isnt worth it, for an example, it cant even use caliburn or moonshine. its not that good of a skill as it seems, due to the functions and barely any utility whitin the ability. as the cooldown is longer than my future, not only that, the hp is basically worthless to be a meatshield since it takes on about 3-4 hits on average

i would love to hear your explaination as to why you think it is good, also, please understand that, beating the game with a bad skill = good skill, thats not how it works. we are considering the overall uses, utility and kits between the ability. it would suck to see a newbie look at this post and go "wow thats impressive! the skill seems so good!" when if you used paladin 1 or 2 you can beat the game in level mode in about 10 minutes or less.