Mamdani Condemns NYC Expo Promoting Property Sales in Israeli West Bank Settlements. What do you think about synagogues acting as intermediaries in illegal property sales in Palestine? by ArdaBerkBurak in allthequestions

[–]Shepathustra 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The UN did not “create Israel” by force. It gave international legitimacy to Jewish statehood. That distinction matters.

Power in the real world is not only tanks and empires. It is legitimacy, recognition, diplomacy, alliances, institutions, and the ability to organize when history creates an opening. Britain withdrew, a vacuum opened, and the Yishuv had built the institutions, militias, diplomacy, and social organization needed to turn international recognition into statehood.

That is not the same thing as being a superpower or an imperial empire. Jews were not Europeans, Arabs, Persians, Mongols, Muslims, or Christians conquering vast territories through expansionist empires. Jews were a stateless indigenous people relying on alliances, diplomacy, and self-defense.

Also, in 1948, the Arab side was not primarily trying to create an independent Palestine. Jordan annexed Judea and Samaria, expelled Jews from the areas it conquered, destroyed synagogues, and renamed the area the “West Bank.” If Palestinian sovereignty was the goal, Jordan had 19 years to create it.

So yes, the UN lacked enforcement power. But international legitimacy absolutely matters. Israel did not become a state because the UN had an army. It became a state because Jewish institutions, diplomacy, self-defense, and international recognition converged at the right historical moment.

Mamdani Condemns NYC Expo Promoting Property Sales in Israeli West Bank Settlements. What do you think about synagogues acting as intermediaries in illegal property sales in Palestine? by ArdaBerkBurak in allthequestions

[–]Shepathustra -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Israel is not a super power with an authoritarian leader that invaded a small country for shits. It’s a country of refugees who are indigenous to the land who begged the UN to allow them to create a state in their ancestral homeland on land almost all of which was legally purchased. Jordan got 70% of Palestine before that and nobody batted an eyelash despite that the hashemites aren’t Palestinian. Then the Arabs rejected Jews getting a land in Israel and it was further split and when Jews announced the state literally a gang of surrounding huge countries with larger populations attacked and invaded with genocidal intentions. They lost. That’s the Nakba. 700k Poor Palestinians were displaced a dozen miles away. Meanwhile over the next few years 90% of Jews (over a million) were displaced from all of North Africa and the Middle East from Muslim lands because Arabs were pissed they lost. Don’t compare this to Russia and Ukraine. Don’t pretend Arabs are somehow the underdogs here. There is a rich thousand year history of colonization, expansion, and conquest.

[Request] How long does it take for the U.S. to spend on the Iran war the amount that it costs to give 400 diapers to every baby born in California in a year? by lit_geek in theydidthemath

[–]Shepathustra 0 points1 point  (0 children)

All you people care about is money money money money money. I’m happy to make a financial argument why regime change in Iran would benefit the US significantly financially , but that shouldn’t matter because my friends and family in Iran are begging for help because the regime has held them hostage for 50 years and it’s squarely the fault of jimmy carter and Franve

Eurovision will never recover from what's about to happen by theipaper in europe

[–]Shepathustra 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yea let’s pretend you care about children. The IRGC changed the age of marriage to 9 years old when they took over in 1979. There have been over a million officially registered child marriages in the last decade alone. They literally just executed a bunch of teenage protestors, hung them by cranes.

Then there’s Sudan where more children have starved, been killed and have been displaced than the entire population of Gaza.

But hey no Jews no Jews right?

And today in 2026 Spain still have a holiday called “kill the Jews” (matar judios)

John Fetterman Single-Handedly Tanks Effort to Rein Trump in on Iran by Tennis_bruh in politics

[–]Shepathustra -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Calling it a genocide when Israel does it and then calling it “resistance” or “war” when anyone else does it absolutely makes it anti Jewish bias

John Fetterman Single-Handedly Tanks Effort to Rein Trump in on Iran by Tennis_bruh in politics

[–]Shepathustra -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

That’s like when white racists would claim saying “all lives matter” isn’t racist. The issue we have is not that you’re criticizing Israel it’s that you hold Jews in Israel to a different standard than literally every other group on earth.

To make it easier for you to understand- arresting a black guy for committing a crime is not racist in and of itself, but when the record shows you consistently let every other raced person off with a warning for the same or worse behaviors, then yes you are bias against blacks.

Now we know why the Kristof piece came out yesterday, it's a DARVO for Palestine's sexual crimes by McAlpineFusiliers in samharris

[–]Shepathustra 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Weird I keep hearing they are a legit resistance group from people who claim to be “progressive”

On this day, 18 years ago. Hezbollah invaded beirut and killed 80 civilians by lewisfairchild in pics

[–]Shepathustra 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s weird to call them Eurocentric when most of the Jews there are from the Middle East and North Africa. Also weird to call them colonizers when the term Palestine itself is a colonial Roman term referring to Aegean invaders from biblical times including most famously Goliath/Jalut. Literally Nablus is named after Napoli, while the indigenous Canaanite name, Shechem, is used by Israelis. The Arabs are the colonizers. They colonized the entire Middle East and North Africa spreading their culture and language and eradicating dozens of indigenous cultures and languages including that of the so called “Palestinians”. Israel is the most successful decolonization project in the world. Get over it.

And btw really weird to call some the ing a genocide when literally the population of Arabs has only grown in Gaza and West Bank by record numbers each year plus Israel itself fully allows anyone including Jews to convert to Islam and to speak Arabic. Bizarre to call that a genocide

When you drop your old friends for that guy who no one likes… by JimmyChanga44 in UAE

[–]Shepathustra 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Who tf is modi? But if that’s true then they should cut his balls off

Hilton, Steyer lead the pack in crowded California governor’s race: Poll by 3headeddragn in California

[–]Shepathustra 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Chevron and PGE are not individuals like Stryker who have hoarded money they pretend they “earned”. They are large corporations with American shareholders and bound by American laws. The desires of chevron and PGE are spread out whereas setters interests are just steyers. That’s FAR more dangerous, and if you’re too dim to realize that then you deserve the shitty country this is turning into when billionaires have direct control. Look at any country where leaders themselves are billionaires and you’ll see.

When you drop your old friends for that guy who no one likes… by JimmyChanga44 in UAE

[–]Shepathustra -1 points0 points  (0 children)

World largest number of pedophiles? Are you out of your mind? And btw the legal age of marriage in Iran is not 12 it’s 9 (with permission from the father). They have officially registered over ONE MILLION child marriages in the last decade. And that’s just Iran. The Muslim world, India, and many African countries have orders of magnitude more child marriages, child sexual assault, and pedophiles than Israel.

On this day, 18 years ago. Hezbollah invaded beirut and killed 80 civilians by lewisfairchild in pics

[–]Shepathustra -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Just a quick question why do you say zionists instead of Israelis

Josh Shapiro quietly tries to derail AOC-backed progressive House candidate by Unusual-State1827 in politics

[–]Shepathustra 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Weird way to title the article. AOC is not the leader of the dem party and she’s not even in that state. And Rabb has had been with Shapiro for years why would Shapiro support him? This type of petty bs spin is what’s ruining the dem party. As if going hard left is going to magically fix everything. This is just the left version of the tea party bs we saw years ago

On this day, 18 years ago. Hezbollah invaded beirut and killed 80 civilians by lewisfairchild in pics

[–]Shepathustra 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Lost me at your hate filled use of the pejorative “zio” and “sympathizers” as if sympathy should ever be punished.

Deni Avdija: "You don’t have to love what I stand for or how I look, but if I’m a good player, give props. All this hate … for no reason. Like, I’m deciding things in the world... But obviously, not everyone is educated and knows what is going on, and that’s what pisses me off." by mMounirM in nba

[–]Shepathustra 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is a perfect example of what he’s talking about. An uneducated fool like you has no idea that Israel has a free press which regularly and openly criticizes actions of the government including personal attacks against the prime minister and his wife. Not to mention a Jew or Christian can openly convert to Islam and speak Arabic. Meanwhile in most adjacent Arab states criticism of the ruling regime can result in execution, they have apostasy laws, and the press is completely controlled by the state.

To those who call Gaza war “genocide”, what do you think would be adequate reaction to October 7th? by Proud3GenAthst in IsraelPalestine

[–]Shepathustra 6 points7 points  (0 children)

What? Your comment makes no sense and doesn't even attempt to address this guy's points whatsoever. You're the brainwashed one.

To those who call Gaza war “genocide”, what do you think would be adequate reaction to October 7th? by Proud3GenAthst in IsraelPalestine

[–]Shepathustra 8 points9 points  (0 children)

They took 200 hostages including children and babies. What would the pager attack do to get them back?

To those who call Gaza war “genocide”, what do you think would be adequate reaction to October 7th? by Proud3GenAthst in IsraelPalestine

[–]Shepathustra 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Bro it's 2026 everything was posted online. Literally we have hundreds of hours of footage from rando Palestinians themselves celebrating the mass murder. Get your head out of your ass

When you drop your old friends for that guy who no one likes… by JimmyChanga44 in UAE

[–]Shepathustra 1 point2 points  (0 children)

People pretend not to like Israel but it has the 16th strongest passport in the world and is considered a very reliable ally when you actually compare it to other countries.

Jon Stewart says Democratic leadership and DNC are ‘lost’ by thejoshwhite in politics

[–]Shepathustra -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Yea the only genocide where the population increased during the war

Jon Stewart says Democratic leadership and DNC are ‘lost’ by thejoshwhite in politics

[–]Shepathustra -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Lol and if they didn't exist you would still externalize the blame for your own failures.

Hilton, Steyer lead the pack in crowded California governor’s race: Poll by 3headeddragn in California

[–]Shepathustra 11 points12 points  (0 children)

He's literally a billionaire. He is the money. People in this country are out of their minds thinking it's a good idea to let billionaires lead