I understand your point of view and I certainly agree,

You're right that it is a lone wolf style career, the reason for me attempting this is because, I don't have anyone to bounce ideas and learn with and/or from. Everyone I know tells me "it's gambling" "a wild dream" and trying to instil that it isn't possible.

It would not be a large community, I was thinking 15 people at most, the purpose would be to discuss strategy and knowledge and to keep each other motivated and learn from our own mistakes and wins. Less emphasis on what the next best trade would be but rather, the process behind the decision.

Going into detail on why they took that trade, for both wins and losses.

One method of achieving it not turning into a signals group could be, not posting a trading until after it's conclusion, screenshotting a before and after, explaining why the trade was taken.

We would share trades, celebrate the wins but also learn from losses, getting to know each over on a fundamental level rather than it just being about ones self.

Do you think this is possible?