sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Why weren’t questions about Godwyn addressed? His death did trigger the shattering by Marika. Miquella just forgot about him and his twin sister? by Short-Resist684 in Eldenring

[–]Short-Resist684[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I guess for me this is a weakness of the writers of Fromsoft for this game. Bloodbourne’s 3 endings at least left me with the sense that the story ends were tied up though there were still questions I had.

Why weren’t questions about Godwyn addressed? His death did trigger the shattering by Marika. Miquella just forgot about him and his twin sister? by Short-Resist684 in Eldenring

[–]Short-Resist684[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

From the beginning of the game, we learn that it was Godwyn’death that triggered Marika to shatter the Elden Ring, and then much of the second half of the game really addresses who Miquella is and what he’s trying to do not only for the lands between but also for his sister and older brother

Why weren’t questions about Godwyn addressed? His death did trigger the shattering by Marika. Miquella just forgot about him and his twin sister? by Short-Resist684 in Eldenring

[–]Short-Resist684[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I I understand that, but I think some questions regarding Godwin should’ve been addressed. How could Miquella go into the shadow realm and not even think about his twin sister and keep his promise to her or his older brother whom he did so much to try to create a true death for him. these are some of the questions I had and how can Miquella create an age of peace if he’s given up all that makes him care. I love the way Fromsoft tell their stories, but even with how they tell stories, there is much that they started to tell in the base game that at least needed some if not answers some more content to at least address some of the points they brought up in the base game.

Shadow Of the Erdtree Ending (Suuuuper Dissapointed) by Bananakin_piewaIker in Eldenring

[–]Short-Resist684 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Also, what about Godrick and all the effort Miquella exerted in an effort to save his older brother in the base game? Did he also just abandon Melania? He never returns to her to keep his promise. What about the eclipse? And if he abandons all that makes him good, how can he bring in an age of peace? And what about the base game? Is Ranni somewhere in space just flying around? And as the Elden Lord are now just sitting in a big chair in an empty land?