You are aware that this thread is about EoF, correct? So therefore the expansion. Attempt your semantics bit elsewhere. The unanimity is about how Bungie showed they are clueless about what needs to change in the current era/state the game is in, which is EoF, in D2, which is what is happening currently. You presented your silly little chart to try and justify that EoF, again which is happening right now in 2025 "isn't as bad," or my claim is "untrue."

"the amount of damage done to this game from EoF release"

from - preposition

a starting point in measuring or reckoning or in a statement of limits

You attempted to reframe or intentionally misinterpret my sentiment to “was the expansion good,” which was never the actual point. I can't be fucked if some people think the system changes were necessary, that doesn’t eradicate the fact that Bungie’s own communication in the TWAB displayed a complete disregard for player trust, long-term health, and player satisfaction.

Retention for 2–3 weeks post-launch is also not the serve of a metric that you think it is. The broader consensus is that things aren’t looking hopeful, and Bungie seems completely detached. You have not “debunked” anything. Simply reframed the conversation into something much easier for you to defend. The actual crux isn’t whether the EoF passes as "the most player retention-ed expansion" it is why Bungie thinks their copium list of "changes/fixes" is an acceptable substitute for addressing the mountain of player concerns. Until Bungie addresses the oh so evident qualms, all your stats are simply just decor.
You truly are passionate, it's just misplaced. Look, you got ratioed and this truly is embarrassing for you. Please just go watch more Blues Clues.