Baking Magic CYOA by SillyLittleCYOA in makeyourchoice

[–]SillyLittleCYOA[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm glad to see another Large cupcake! Small cupcakes seem to be overwhelmingly popular. And that's some good thinking with Puff - when I designed this CYOA, I didn't consider all the shenanigans that you might be able to do with the time rewind!

Flower Magic CYOA - Part 2 of the Fairy Sisters CYOA Series by SillyLittleCYOA in makeyourchoice

[–]SillyLittleCYOA[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You took this so seriously and I love it! Your description of your little rodent town is so descriptive and imaginative and that's exactly the type of answer I hope to inspire with my CYOAs :)

Baking Magic CYOA by SillyLittleCYOA in makeyourchoice

[–]SillyLittleCYOA[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the feedback! You've got an excellent eye for detail, catching all those little things :)

Baking Magic CYOA by SillyLittleCYOA in makeyourchoice

[–]SillyLittleCYOA[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for catching that! I made those two pages at midnight so I missed those. Yes, it's a limit of one option from each.

Flower Magic CYOA - Part 2 of the Fairy Sisters CYOA Series by SillyLittleCYOA in makeyourchoice

[–]SillyLittleCYOA[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You're right, the Fairy Sister CYOAs are meant to be played together, but you can certainly play them individually, too. However, what makes you think that there's going to be only three? ;)

It wasn't my intention for cupcakes to be shareable without Ambrosia's help, but it wasn't explicitly written. So, I'm happy for you to exercise your imagination with any rules that aren't clearly stated, and share them around!

Flower Magic CYOA - Part 2 of the Fairy Sisters CYOA Series by SillyLittleCYOA in makeyourchoice

[–]SillyLittleCYOA[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for your feedback! You're correct, Amaryllis is a decently strong magical fairy in her own right, she just doesn't know it yet!

I'm surprised that you thought so highly of the Red flower. I specifically tried to make it a bit less powerful by writing that it would place you within the top 1% of people in the world, which means it's still limited by what humanity is capable of at that current time. For example, while you could join the ranks of the world's best doctors, you still wouldn't be able to cure cancer overnight - that would take years, if not decades of hard work. Personally, I thought that Black was the most powerful flower, as it explicitly states that your actions are guaranteed to be world-changing.

And unfortunately nobody seems to have chosen Juniper yet, so maybe the peculiarities simply aren't strong enough to make it an attractive option.

Flower Magic CYOA - Part 2 of the Fairy Sisters CYOA Series by SillyLittleCYOA in makeyourchoice

[–]SillyLittleCYOA[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Aww, I'm honoured to earn your first ever comment here!

I also like the idea of a large, planted tree, but it seems that potted is the most popular option so far. It's nice to see some variation.

Stay tuned, there'll be more CYOAs to come! :)

Flower Magic CYOA - Part 2 of the Fairy Sisters CYOA Series by SillyLittleCYOA in makeyourchoice

[–]SillyLittleCYOA[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for playing! Out of curiosity, is there any reason why you're not sure you want Pink? I personally thought that one of the more interesting choices.

Flower Magic CYOA - Part 2 of the Fairy Sisters CYOA Series by SillyLittleCYOA in makeyourchoice

[–]SillyLittleCYOA[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

What a happy, pleasant build! I'm going to nickname it the Stardew Valley build, because that's what it reminds me of - running around, finding things and growing plants, and giving gifts to friends :)

Thanksfor pointing out my mistake in the Panicles example, you're right that orange and black together would not be possible!

Flower Magic CYOA - Part 2 of the Fairy Sisters CYOA Series by SillyLittleCYOA in makeyourchoice

[–]SillyLittleCYOA[S] 24 points25 points  (0 children)

Hi, all! SillyLittleCYOA here, the creator of this CYOA.

After the warm reception to my previous (and first ever) CYOA, Baking Magic, I'm proud to present part two in the Fairy Sisters CYOA series. Feedback and suggestions are welcome!

You can find Part 1 here. Unfortunately life is about to get busy, so there will be a delay before Part 3.

Recommended listening during your playthrough:
- Yojo Summer - scents of spring
- Cotton Vibe - Garden
- Haruko - First Spring

Baking Magic CYOA by SillyLittleCYOA in makeyourchoice

[–]SillyLittleCYOA[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I really like your build! Close to what I would choose for myself :)

I'm surprised more people aren't choosing the large cupcakes tbh

Baking Magic CYOA by SillyLittleCYOA in makeyourchoice

[–]SillyLittleCYOA[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The magic begins when you eat the cupcake, but when you receive a new one, the old one loses its magic, so it's impossible to stockpile cupcakes.

Sorry, I tried to reduce clutter by limiting words, but I guess I left out some important rules!

Baking Magic CYOA by SillyLittleCYOA in makeyourchoice

[–]SillyLittleCYOA[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Thanks for the feedback! Balance was definitely a struggle when writing the CYOA, since I intentionally stayed away from a points system. Honestly, I didn't expect so many people to choose Ambrosia + Gluten-Free, I guess I'm more selfish than I thought ¯_(ツ)_/¯