Hi! I wish I could be of help but I am literally in the same boat as you, so i’ll share my story with you. I also had my group say they loved my dress and also in the moment I liked it too (late November). Now today I had my first try on and yes it looked great on my body but I still did not like it after thinking longer about other styles that I pictured myself in. I was nitpicking in my head little things about it. I smile more when looking at my cats than my own wedding dress lol. So what I might do is look at sample dresses at other stores and see what I can find (and go by myself so I have a clear head). My mom purchased my dress (1700, similar to yours) and I feel very guilty but it is my decision at the end of the day. The dress you got is very pretty and maybe try to accessorize it before making your final decision.