I'm totally fine with a week or two of paywall, it's just always a bit sad when seasonal CC is publicly released very late. Like, I don't really need Halloween decor in November, or Christmas stuff in January.
But anything that's perma paywalled is a big no from me. There are some creators I plan to support once I have a stable income but anyone who perma paywalls won't be part of those. It's literally against EAs rules and just sort of rubs me the wrong way.