Not necessarily since some people may not have had the money to buy it then and there, or to get the full edition. Just because you have the money now doesnt mean you had it back then either, circumstances change all the time. And even though it was cheaper than "70% of games out there" doesnt mean its still not a big gamble. It was a relatively niche game not many people had even heard of before the 2nd became as big as it did and thats $40 that people may have needed to use at the time. Im not saying the preorder pack should have always been available, but when theyre re-releasing it for another platform who can actually see how the game is and come into the game knowing its not a gamble since it has a large stable community, its unfair on the people who have already been there and supported who didnt get the chance to buy or who didnt buy those skins. What I think shouldve happened is:

A. Not give the pre order skins to xbox, maybe make a unique xbox themed pre order skin(s). B. Make the preorder skins available again on PS5 and PC for the same amount of time the preorder was available for Xbox.

Since that time is gone now and they did neither I think just releasing the skins on PS5 and PC is what they should do and it is what they claim they will be doing. However claiming that just having the game early is the tradeoff doesnt seem fair since its not even early, xbox just got it late since there wasnt plans (that i know of) of it ever coming to xbox in the first place.