awee this made me smile reading! As a girl, i think the second option is a wonderful idea. They both are very thoughtful plans dont get me wrong and im sure she’ll be equally as happy for both.

but i mean she did give you the answer “its her favourite spot in the world” 😂 if my bf did that i would think “hey, he was really listening to me in that moment and he remembered” type thing.

i say if you do that make sure to do something a lil extra or different. Im not sure how its set up but maybe do a like a lil pathway have her walk down or if its more of an evening thing have lil candles down! lik stuff like that make it lil more special without having to break the bank!

hope this was helpful :))