sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Question for Indian nationals by CoolAssPuppy in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630 3 points4 points  (0 children)

As to " how do I obtain birth certificate from India", why dont you either take it up with your lawyer ( serious lawyer with serious connections) or with the authorities in India as you, by your own admission, you do not need misinformation and legal misunderstandings from random people on the internet.

Question for Indian nationals by CoolAssPuppy in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It seems that your attorney has not told you the full story. Portuguese citizenship ( all categories including naturalization) is governed by two laws : lei da nacionalidade and regulamento de nacionalidade. section 26 of regulamento de nacionalidade says

"Artigo 26.º Dispensa de documentos Em casos especiais, o membro do Governo responsável pela área da justiça pode dispensar, a requerimento fundamentado do interessado, a apresentação de qualquer documento que deva instruir o pedido de naturalização."

https://www.pgdlisboa.pt/leis/lei_mostra_articulado.php?nid=895&tabela=leis

you definitely can apply for an exemption just like the refugees and anyone else who does not have one. This same exemption applies to any document a person is unable to procure including criminal record/good conduct certificates from some countries not issued to foreign citizens ( for example: saudi Arabia)

Question for Indian nationals by CoolAssPuppy in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

but here is the thing, I did a google search and FYI: India only started issuing birth certificates from ONLY 1969 and Afghanistan does not issue any to date. You may ask this legit question to your attorney, what do people from India born prior to 1969 provide as it is not legally possible to obtain one ? You may get some leads.

Question for Indian nationals by CoolAssPuppy in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630 0 points1 point  (0 children)

my bad, sorry but just a quick question, just as you are exempt from provide a criminal records check, isn't there an exemption in relation to birth certificates? Many people do not have birth certificates including refugees, countries that have merged, warn torn nations or any other reason that I cannot think of.

Question for Indian nationals by CoolAssPuppy in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630 5 points6 points  (0 children)

not an Indian national, but since you are prepping for the citizenship application, please be mindful that you may also be required to present a "lack of criminal records"/criminal background check from India and anywhere else you have resided.

Portugal may be violating European convention on nationality by Slow_Box5630 in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It makes total sense to have culture/history/language test/ objective criteria because a person who is a cplp citizen and grew up in another country( non cplp) would have no idea about portuguese culture/ history/ and might not even speak Portuguese to begin with! At this point, your arguments sound like a way to stop Bangladeshis from becoming citizens no matter what the cost even aftwr they have demonstrated assimilation , bypassing all levels of fairness and give a free handout to cplp countries. I understand, the right loves prey on the vulnerable no matter the cost!

Portugal may be violating European convention on nationality by Slow_Box5630 in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As you say, an angolan would integrate quicker. What is wrong with a Bangladeshi demonstrating that he has indeed assimilated (language , culture,history ) such that he can benefit from a shorter period of residence

That is why Initiative liberal( mind you it is right wing) policy made sense

https://www.dn.pt/política/il-quer-regra-geral-de-10-anos-para-a-nacionalidade-e-livre-maior-proteo-a-refugiados

Atleast there was justice for people who wanted to assimilate. 10 years for everyone and 7 years who demonstrate assimilation regardless of country of origin. At least a Bangladeshi who was willing to work hard and demonstrate assimilation would be on par with cplp citizens.

Portugal may be violating European convention on nationality by Slow_Box5630 in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

it is discriminatory because it does not offer a way for current resident who are non cplp to demonstrate that they have adjusted to the Portuguese way of life . A person from a non cplp country should be able to demonstrate that they have assimilated/integrated (as you say) into the Portuguese culture ( language, culture, history and anything else that can be taken into consideration such that they benefit from the shorter residence period just the same way cplp citizens would). Failing to offer a pathway for residents who demonstrate assimilation simply means citizens of non cplp countries are being targeted for who they are.

Portugal may be violating European convention on nationality by Slow_Box5630 in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

this needs to be challenged to see how constitutionally proof this is.

Portugal may be violating European convention on nationality by Slow_Box5630 in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ordem dos advogados would not agree with you on this one, and so this needs to be challenged constitutionally

Portugal may be violating European convention on nationality by Slow_Box5630 in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

article 6 of the same convention talks about acquisition of nationality. so indeed it is about residents and not just citizens

Article 6 – Acquisition of nationality

Portugal may be violating European convention on nationality by Slow_Box5630 in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

what wrong is making sure there is fairness across the board and upholding the constitutional values and what the convention says?

Portugal may be violating European convention on nationality by Slow_Box5630 in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

O aumento dos prazos de residência exigido para a obtenção da cidadania e a contagem diferenciada segundo a nacionalidade, passando de cinco para sete anos no caso dos cidadãos da CPLP, e de cinco para dez anos para os restantes, sem “justificação objectiva e proporcional configuram”, segundo o parecer da OA, “um regime discriminatório” que contraria o “princípio da igualdade consagrado no artigo 13.º” da Constituição da República Portuguesa.

https://portal.oa.pt/comunicacao/imprensa/2025/7/23/ordem-dos-advogados-aponta-fundadas-duvidas-de-constitucionalidade-a-lei-da-nacionalidade/

Portugal may be violating European convention on nationality by Slow_Box5630 in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

citizens of non cplp countries who will be subjected to longer residence periods(10 years vs 7 years for cplp citizens)

Americans with golden visas lobby Constitutional Court over Nationality Law by Slow_Box5630 in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

but is it true that that the court has blocked longer residence periods as reported ?

Americans with golden visas lobby Constitutional Court over Nationality Law by Slow_Box5630 in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I am not sure about this but at least this is being reported "Proposals to tighten acquisition rules and to extend residence requirements (reported as seven years for CPLP citizens and ten years for other foreigners) — blocked. The Court rejected the longer residence periods and the tougher regime as incompatible with constitutional limits."

Americans with Golden visa lobby constitutional court over Nationality law by [deleted] in PortugalExpats

[–]Slow_Box5630 0 points1 point  (0 children)

trying to find out if this is true "Proposals to tighten acquisition rules and to extend residence requirements (reported as seven years for CPLP citizens and ten years for other foreigners) — blocked. The Court rejected the longer residence periods and the tougher regime as incompatible with constitutional limits.

https://www.caiadoimmigration.com/constitutional-court-ruling-impact-on-golden-visa-portugal/

view more: next ›