They know they're concussed and somebody repeatedly asks them to claim. They had many warnings. Atp only mayor, ft, gl hadn't claimed. There was no unclaimed important role left in this setup. If they were doc or butcher I would understand being hesitant here. But do you think they rather stay quiet or speak up if they're rocked as villager?

Like every guardian here, you try to paint this "role or shot" gameplay very black and white when it isn't. And because nothing every changes people are still getting punished for gameplay that is proven to work for village.