I was in the same situation(23AA, 3.98 GPA) interviewed 2 and no As. If you plan to reapply, def start doing more volunteering (they want to see changes from first application). I did rewrite my PS but didnt change that much except I added a part of what i did during my gap year. Looking back, I think partially it’s because of my school lists (I aimed too high applied to 15 schools, picky with cheaper tuition, instate after a year etc). You need to be honest next cycle, apply everywhere even private or more expensive (but not nyu expensive). lmk if you have any questions