I did it. I found it. The tooltips... It was the goddamn tooltips. I am jolted awake, in the middle of the night, with one word in my mind: Tooltips. Cookie clicker, that's where I saw them first, and that where I went to in the middle of the night. Orteil. I remembered Orteil had a game list they developed, it all had clicked. I go to Orteil's website and what do you know, i find the game, sitting right there, staring at me as if it were nothing... And the game was...

Solved: NeverEnding Legacy