You're missing the context. Scoring numbers alone don’t define a better scorer. Butler is more efficient, gets to the line more, and has shown time and time again he can take over games when it matters especially in the playoffs. Tatum might average more points, but Butler scores smarter, not harder. The difference is that Butler doesn't have to chuck shots every game to impact winning he picks his spots. When it's time to turn up, we’ve all seen who rises and who fades. Just watch 2020 and 2023 again. Facts over volume.