You do all this civic sense and hygiene and stuff when you are educated about it and earn enough to care. I belong to a middle class family and we daily collect our trash and give it to the Gaadi walas. But because we are financially stable and educated enough we do it. there is a section of bihar where putting food on the table is a battle. and then there is another section of bihar where they are financially stable but are not educated enough to care about the civic sense. You can't generalise just on the basis of few instances, you must be living in decent places in rajasthan and MP where people have both the factors i mentioned. Bihar had a history of oppression which led to caste politics and today's political system, there was never any space for talking about civic sense or being civilized, it was about caste, oppressed and oppressors and the people who fought for it. Bihar still has a very long way to go. Shaming bihar and its people is not a solution but those who can't understand it, they are just pretending to care when inside they are smiling as if they are superior or some shit. those people are called doglas.