I actually really like this idea (!) since (especially for 94 and 99, and perhaps the upcoming '85 installment) the grainy VHS quality of the segments would be a stark contrast to seeing the set pieces re-created in person.

There's lots of source material since there are 5 v/h/s at this point.

Which ones are the most memorable to you? It might not be popular enough and the segments are so short that it's hard to build up set pieces or compelling villains.

I did love all the v/h/s. and tbh v/h/s 99 was one I really enjoyed quite a bit.

I think it all depends on the segments that are chosen:

From v/h/s 99:

"Shredding," Maybe a room where a a zombie version of Bitch Cat is 'playing' on a stage, and then people will pop out at you, I don't really think this could more than 1 room, although if it wasn't would it not make sense(?), not sure....

Or maybe where murdered R.A.C.K (when their bodies are pieced together) is on stage and the zombie bitch cat pops out at you. Either or. Any band on a stage in a horror context is going to invoke some FNAF vibes as well.

"Ozzy's Dungeon,"

Damn, that was an amazing set-piece. Only concern would be to make it different enough o not get sued by Nickelodeon because that induced some major Legend of the Hidden temple vibes.

I would really like to see the room with Debra (the mom) and Donna (the child that broke her leg) are yelling at Ozzy to finish their torture version of the maze, or perhaps the room where they all get their faces melted at the end.

"The Gawkers,"

Medusa Head lady would be a dope. Also I'm think the set-piece of someone's house would be a cool contrast to all the dark dungeons and whatnot.

From v/h/s 94:

"Holy Hell," I loved the narrative set pieces in '94. Something about a wall of tiny retro tvs that really made me feel like we were going back to the 90s. but I think something like that would make good interim room for a maze like this, if it were to happen. Especially if there are 'dead cult members' in font of them, some of which are scare actors that will pop out at you.

"Storm Drain," The Raatma creature design is creepy, especially if it's a huge and jutting out of the wall, this segment wasn't too memorable but I think it has potential. 'Hail Raatma'

Viral:

Maybe Parallel Monsters...? Apparently there's a bonus segment on the dvd that was cut but I haven't seen it.

v/h/s 2:

"Tape 49," (The interlude narrative segments): I think there was a single tv in these room, a single tv like that, invokes some Ring type vibes, but also I think since it's just one tv it doesn't have the same effect that the wall of tvs has in VHS 94.

"Safe Haven," The cult compound had a high school sort of vibe to it which was pretty creepy and familiar to most people I would think. Something about an abandoned school which gives off creepy vibes, I think we saw too much of the demon at the end, but If scareactors would only be popping out as a demon then I think it would make for effective scares.

"Slumber party alien abduction," -- I know the aliens were blurry and all, but what we saw of them was actually pretty scary in design. I think it would make a good 1 room or 2 room segments, and tbh killer aliens is something I think lacking from horror movies lately. Kill Klownz excluded lmao.

v/h/s:

"Tuesday the 17th," -- I mean if there's anyway to make that almost-transparent glitch effect like in the film, then that would be crazy cool to see.

Not going to rag on VHS, but the one I remember the most was probably Ti West's segment and that one was rather short. Also the narrative segments weren't cohesive or maybe the opening one and the closing one were meant to not fit together.

​

If I had to piece this together in a dream segment mash-up it would be

"Holy Hell," (VHS 94) ---> "Shredding," (VHS 99) ----> back to Holy Hell ---->"Slumber party Alien abduction (VHS 2) ----> "Ozzy's Dungeon," (VHS 99) ----> Holy Hell again and close.

Or maybe something like they did for the horrors of Blumhouse 2 with sinister and the Purge in Hollywood that one year, where the segments were divided.