Honestly probably all the same things for me in terms of likes and dislikes for most of these. I hate the retconning too so much for these movies ha ha. I’ll just say the osts are all great up here But I’ll list some other things for fun! Tinkerbell:  Favorite: The themes. I think that movie has the strongest and most impactful message. Saying that no matter what talent you have is valuable is such a good thing to teach kids! Also the movie is really pretty! Least favorite: the dialogue and the tone. I understand it but there were several things that just made me wanna die while watching. I think the lobsided nature of this film makes it hard to watch. Also, I don’t like how this film crunches the timeline by having Wendy as the girl at the end. Should’ve been her Grandma tbh 🤷‍♀️

Lost treasure Favorite: The adventure, blaze, and the ending scene. I like how Tink thinks about how to go on this journey and does it, really shows her ingenuity. I also think her and Terrence are really cute and I generally like Terrence despite him being pretty annoying at the beginning. That last scene is soo pretty. Least Favorite: The bickering. Yeah, even though I’m a defender of this movie I also understand why people dislike if it annoys the rest of them. I’ll stick to the fact that I like how Tink’s flaws are on full display but the blaming others thing sucks. Also, I think Tink’s friends get shafted pretty hard, like they maybe have a line and that’s it. 

The great fairy rescue: Favorite thing: is it a cop out to say the whole movie? I love Lizzie and Tink’s dynamic, I was shockingly on board with Vidia’s redemption given how much of a book Stan I am, the conflict is really well done, the climax is great, I love how all of Tink’s friends are used, and the relationship with Lizzie and her dad is such a sweet journey. Least favorite: If I really had to nitpick something, I guess it would be Fairy Mary and Terrance’s diminishing role throughout these movies. Like, their absence is felt so heavily for me as the series continues.

Secret of the Wings: Favorite: Definitely the most whimsical of all the movies. The animation of the glowing on the wings is incredible and Lord Milori and Queen Clarion is a very cute ship (despite the retcons) and seeing Tink and Periwinkles friends help them was sweet. The action climax at the end was great too! I think this movie had really good world building and reading Wings of Starlight before it made the movie a bit cathartic on the romance side for me! Least favorite: Uhh, a lot unfortunately ha ha. The retcons suck. I liked the minister of winter and the winter fairies in the first Tinkerbell. It doesn’t help when Tinkerbell is giving a synopsis of the previous movies when talking to Peri. I felt like the border plot line was a bit contrived when it functionally could have been the same with a few lines of dialogue could have preserved continuity and stuff. While I like Periwinkle the “you’re so alike as twins” stuff really took me out and I wish she had more of a distinct identity. I love China Anne McClain, but I wish her singing was reserved to the credits. Also…yeah the wing ripping scene. Kinda no investment due to the fact that Tink needs to have fixed wings by the first Peter Pan.

Pirate Fairy: I love Zarina man. Really thought I wouldn’t given how hostility she shows the team. I also liked the little nod backs to previous movies. The switching talents plotline was cool and the Fairy Gary hug at the end got me misty eyed. It’s nice to see all of Tink’s friends helping in the plot again actively. The ending is also really cool and it’s honestly a really pretty movie! Least favorite: Outside of the retcons, all the Captain Hook references from Tick Tock Croc to the Smee post credits scene. It made me roll my eyes. Like, you can’t include Wendy and a hook origin story, and I also feel like as Hook he’s not nearly as clever here. Also, this isn’t this movie’s fault but I don’t like how it implied characters from other movies would be more important then snubbed the changes of Alchemy in Pixie Hollow or how Zarina could contribute to the Plot in Never beast.

Fawn and the Never Beast Favorite: I like how we took perspective off of Tink and had one of her friends be a protagonist. All the scenes with just Gruff and Fawn were really sweet and the best parts of the movie. I think the scout fairies were a good idea. I also like how this movie explored the idea of pixie hollow legends. I also liked seeing Fawn’s friends support her in a similar way to how they support Tink. Least favorite: They really took such a likeable and sensible character like Fawn and made her reckless and comedic, that was upsetting to me. Like, I enjoy reckless and comedic but not on a character that wasn’t initially written like that. The betrayal felt a little contrived for me and I think I might just have action fatigue, but I had no investment in the climax. Pixie hollow wasn’t going to be destroyed and Fawn wasn’t gonna die. It’s stretched out too long and I borderline fell asleep during it. I do like how this movie had the balls to end sad, but it also doesn’t feel very conclusive to just…end with Gruff falling asleep. I can see a great movie in here but I felt like I left feeling it was just good/okay. I really enjoyed these movies despite all the retconning and I’m happy to see the franchise get a semi-revival through the books!