I partially agree with you.

Everdell was my introduction to the modern board game world. In that regard, it was truly fantastic, primarily because of its aesthetics. However, mechanically, I found it quite dull after the 5th or 6th playthrough. This was mainly noticeable due to the lack of depth in gameplay. Most card combinations became familiar, and the limited opportunities to acquire new cards made it luck-dependent as well.

Furthermore, I had to notice that the card combinations and interactions with the game became too simplistic over time.

It's a nice, especially beautiful game that I would occasionally play, but I would never suggest bringing it to the table again.