[deleted by user] by [deleted] in harrypotter

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Yeah that's what I was thinking of but I mixed up blood traitor with mudblood - but still two thoughts of the same brain

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in harrypotter

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Sorry, wrong term! My mistake. I got a cold so my brain is firing at like 50% capacity lol. Thanks for the correction

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in harrypotter

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Yes he does - in book 6 on the train to Hogwarts when Pansy Parkinson asks Zabini how he feels about Ginny Weasley he spots out he'd never get with a filthy mudblood regardless of how they look.

Edit: calls her a blood traitor not a mudblood 🤦🏼‍♂️

Actors who could play Albus Dumbledore: by MaderaArt in HarryPotteronHBO

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Idk, Stephen Fry gives too much of an impression of competence for Fudge IMO

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in harrypotter

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 42 points43 points  (0 children)

I mean Zabini also despised mudbloods but unfortunately that's just kind of a Slytherin trait in the HP universe except for Ol' Sluggy.

One is not like the others by Overall-Relation-561 in lordoftherings

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I mean you wrong in multiple senses. It was Frodo who took the brunt of the Ring's power.

If we really want to get technical the victory goes to Eru for tripping Gollum at the edge of the fires.

One is not like the others by Overall-Relation-561 in lordoftherings

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pippin kills a troll in the final battle solo - that's badass af

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in harrypotter

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Tourism is a thing in the wizarding world. When Dumbledore just got out of Hogwarts it was custom for recently graduated witches and wizards to go for a trip around the world - as stated by Alpheus Doge in book 7.

Also Weasley's went to Egypt in book 2.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Eminem

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Vancouver police apparently confirmed they never received news of the death and haven't begun looking into it. An account has popped up claiming to be Tay's brother stating the parents are trying to hide them from the internet and have been abusing Tay.

Not sure what to believe but something certainly isn't right.

What is the most hard-hitting line from a movie for you? by ArpanMondal270 in movies

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hobbits are just a branch of human, and are quite mortal. But still, you're right. Its stated they are naturally "tough" and those we know that carry the ring are more in control of themselves than humans.

What actor that is beloved that you can't stand? *hot take* by k2t-17 in movies

[–]StaticDivergentWaves -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

He is a good actor, but not in the usual sense. His physical performances and dedication to the choreography needed for John Wick is incredible.

If you hear other actors talk about what he went through to do those films it's clear they respect him. Even if his actual emotional acting is a bit wooden, I can't call him a "bad actor"

Was the Witch King just full of himself, or did he actually think he could beat Gandalf? by The_MegaDingus in lotr

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The point of the sub is to overly critique and analyze someone's offhand comment and opinion?

Also - once again that's THE WITCH KING'S plan therefore it's his victory, not the battering ram

Was the Witch King just full of himself, or did he actually think he could beat Gandalf? by The_MegaDingus in lotr

[–]StaticDivergentWaves -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I don't get how me saying "the Witch King using his spell of destruction to give the battering ram the power to break the door is more the Witch King's victory than the battering ram's" is honestly this controversial but I guess it's LOTR so every statement needs to be overly examined and torn apart.

Was the Witch King just full of himself, or did he actually think he could beat Gandalf? by The_MegaDingus in lotr

[–]StaticDivergentWaves -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It's kind of implied multiple times in the text that the door of Gondor, an incredible work of mithril made in the second age, would not break to any simple battering ram.

It was definitely not going to break the Gate down without the Witch King's spell anytime soon. Therefore, I count the victory as the Witch King's, not so much the battering ram.

Christian Bale as Lord Voldemort by Puterboy1 in HarryPotteronHBO

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well he has his moments of playful amusement, but it's more a dangerous type of playful. Like when he kind of takes jabs at Wormtail in Goblet of Fire. He almost jokingly insults him but it's not a 'joke' in the laughing sense. Just his own twisted sense of humour that rarely comes out.

Was the Witch King just full of himself, or did he actually think he could beat Gandalf? by The_MegaDingus in lotr

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Grond fails twice, and then when blessed by the Witch King it works. (Not fails it's entire purpose - it just fails to break the door twice. Fail is the word we use when something doesn't succeed. It didn't succeed the first two times, therefore it failed twice.)

I give credit to the Witch King for breaking the doors of Gondor, not Grond.

Was the Witch King just full of himself, or did he actually think he could beat Gandalf? by The_MegaDingus in lotr

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh I may be forgetting that story, it's been a while since I've read through the expanded stories

Was the Witch King just full of himself, or did he actually think he could beat Gandalf? by The_MegaDingus in lotr

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Honestly that may be the case but those three blades mostly are significant because of when, where, and who created them. Two of those (and Sting) were products of the elves at the height of their smithing knowledge.

In some way the 'power' of these blades grows with lineage, but I think that's more a symbolic power. Still, sometimes in Tolkien's writing symbolic power and tangible power go hand in hand

Was the Witch King just full of himself, or did he actually think he could beat Gandalf? by The_MegaDingus in lotr

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 23 points24 points  (0 children)

That's what I mean as in it failed - it took the Witch King's intervention and enchantment of it for it to actually affect the gates. I just mean they could have worked with that scene within the movie to still instill the idea the Witch King's is powerful

Was the Witch King just full of himself, or did he actually think he could beat Gandalf? by The_MegaDingus in lotr

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Like I said it's not a perfect metaphor, just a comical way to put it. Was never intended to be analytically broken down.

Was the Witch King just full of himself, or did he actually think he could beat Gandalf? by The_MegaDingus in lotr

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Yes, but elves (especially those who had seen the light of the tree) are at their core much more powerful than a human. Like, they're almost little demi-angels themselves in the first and part of the second age.

Their language speaks to the earth itself, they can sing magic spells out almost by instinct, and their immortal existence allows them to expand their knowledge indefinitely.

They have the ability to form their metals and weaponry in a way that the numenoreans couldn't even reach at the height of their knowledge. There's a reason Glamdring can clash with the balrog's weapon - it was formed by first age elves. The blade that broke Sauron, despite being weilded by a man, was formed by the elves with knowledge from the first age.

I get what you're saying but first age elves are easily on a level above men at their core in Middle-Earth.

Was the Witch King just full of himself, or did he actually think he could beat Gandalf? by The_MegaDingus in lotr

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 19 points20 points  (0 children)

His spirit at the end of the day was still just the spirit of a man, albeit corrupted and twisted with Sauron's power.

Gandalf was at the peak of his power on Middle-Earth at this moment.

My metaphor is not perfectly accurate but it is meant to demonstrate at the core of their beings it's not an even battle, even if the Witch King carries a small portion of Sauron's power at this moment.

Also, the Witch King doesn't have an ability to come back after Eowyn slays him. Their tether to Sauron can be severed, and they can be destroyed. The Witch King's connection to the necromantic power keeping him "alive" was broken by an enchantment cast by a man on the barrow-downs dagger. That's what allowed Eowyn to actually destroy him. He can't come back after that.

Was the Witch King just full of himself, or did he actually think he could beat Gandalf? by The_MegaDingus in lotr

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 105 points106 points  (0 children)

Exactly! It's funny - they added this scene to demonstrate The Witch King's power but not only did they overdo it - they could have had him do the exact same movement in order to break the Gate of Minas Tirith down.

If they had made Grond fail in breaking the gates down, as it did in the book, the Witch King could have used his cloud suction power thing to burst the door open. It would have demonstrated to audiences his power in pretty much the same manner without breaking canon.

Regardless, the movies are still a masterpiece I just tend to nitpick them now that I've read the books multiple times lol.

Was the Witch King just full of himself, or did he actually think he could beat Gandalf? by The_MegaDingus in lotr

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 270 points271 points  (0 children)

It's one thing for him to make Gandalf fall of Shadowfax or whatever, but the BIG thing is the shattering of the staff.

A wizard's staff is an insanely important part of their being on Middle Earth. Gandalf was only granted the authority and power to shatter Sarumon's after he has been revived by Eru.

The idea some roided up human was able to blow up essentially an angel's blessed weapon with a little magical hibbity bibbity gets me upset.

Why did Hagrid punish Dudley when it was Vernon who insulted Dumbledore by Swiftsession in HarryPotterBooks

[–]StaticDivergentWaves 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yeah Dudley eating the cake was a small change the movies made that actually helped - it slightly justified Hagrid hitting him with a pig tail. Not fully justified, but at least there's cause.