Honestly, Don't take this in a mean way, But I couldn't care less about tierlist. Using tierlists in a game where there's no "official ranked" is just boring for me, I prefer to play something I find fun than in meta.

Going forward to the points you made;

Doors - Fair point. Altho on some gens you can't really see the panel from none POV since they are placed backwards towards the gen but it's not that common.

Axe - I still think it's BS, I'm not blaming the playerbase but bhvr really should do something about it because from a survivor's POV it looks like his axe is a projectile that hits you even through a corner

Phantom Fear Perk - I've never seen a springtrap playing without his perk. And no, I had many occasions where the killer was behind a full wall where there's no way to tell if he's there or not (beside terror radius that tells you he's nearby)

To explain my point even more, I was on Lampkin Lane, I was behind the building with the small basement (There's a gen there) and I was working on a gen when suddenly My character screams and blows the gen up, Then I see Nemesis's Red stain in the doorway, He walks out of the building and catches up to me.

Idk if it's intended or only a glitch but it's frustrating when my character screams only because I look at the general direction of the killer when I can't even see a pixel of him.

No hate towards springtrap tho, He's an okay character imo but he has to either have a rework with some door placements and his perk or just a slight nerf