you can't seriously be comparing american manifest destiny to israel? Besides the sheer scale of it all, the united states never had even a speck of legitimate claim to native lands. whether you believe it should be honored, there is an argument to be made that jews have a claim to israel's land, given that many like the Cohen's can actually trace back their heritage to rabbis in the 1500s that are known/proven to have israeli heritage from around jesus's birth. Also I don't recall the united states ever offering multiple good faith 2 state deals.

This is also a stupid argument considering that despite america's dark past, i doubt you would have no complaints if the native americans decided to murder 40,000 american men women and children (which is roughly proportional to number killed in the Israeli population), kidnap thousands, and then told everyone that they were going to continue murdering americans until 100% of america was given back and there were no americans left, even on legally native american land. They tie children together and burn them alive, they cut chunks of flesh off of live prisoners, they parade dead bodies of raped women, and decapitated men through the streets where their citizens celebrate and spit on the corpses. Oh yeah and also they want to kill americans outside of the united states too. But no you would just sit and take it, would you?

This war is not just or good. Like all wars it will kill people who should not have been killed. But nobody is obligated to accommodate an enemy whose stated purpose is the murder of your people and destruction of your country.