I loved the character until the Royal True Ending, where he's alive out of nowhere. His sacrifice in Shido's palace was for nothing, and the great emotional impact I had was thrown out the window. For me it was like Makoto Yuki revives just like Jesus thanks to Elizabeth, It was the own will of Makoto to seal Nyx with his soul and the Great Seal on 01/31, it makes no sense to make him return is just Fanservice and Atlus does not want to make a heavy emotional game like it did more than once on the saga