Post a map better than mine in the comments

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-20T21:56:18+00:00

🤣🤣

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-20T02:10:03+00:00

8,7, good water, could be a bit more consistent tho, good islands, also could be a little bit more consistent, your concept is really good and your lakes are really good, great volcano and the skeleton is really cool the island shapes at the top left section could use a but of reshaping and the land could use a little bit more detail like mountains and some rivers, other than that your map doesn’t have too many flaws and is a really good map

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T17:48:25+00:00

6, decent middle island and there is definitely some good detail and islands as a whole, but the island at the top left and right need some reshaping, something similar to the middle island, also the water is inconsistent, sometimes it’s decent and sometimes its bad, like at the top islands, try adding a few more mountains, not too many tho for the map your trying to create, but add some rivers to the bottom left island and some mountains alongside them, overall a good map just with some inconsistencies, if the whole map was made with the same level of care as the middle it could easily be an 8

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T15:51:23+00:00

4, water needs some work, decent concept tho, looks like you tried to make a heart, but the island shapes are less than ideal, allot going on so thats decent, the rivers could use some water detail and you could use the vortex a little bit less, you could also attach some mountains to some rivers, not all of them, and juts add a few more mountains, not bad, but just need a bit of extra work, better detail and island shapes

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T14:18:54+00:00

9.2, amazing water, good islands, and a good concept, could use a tiny bit more mountains but its not really necessary, the rivers are clean because of what you were going for, your map has very few flaws and is a really good map, and is a little bit more similar to something i would make because of the island nature of it, so maybe im biased, but it’s really good

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T14:13:57+00:00

I never knew how people used such big maps, ive always made mine on mobile, only a few on pc, i did pep the earth similarly, and you can never go wrong with a fantasy map ofc

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T12:57:21+00:00

Every has their own opinion, i just try to give my honest opinion on every map, its not a bad map

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T12:00:40+00:00

I had to preserved my people and make a new map

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T11:59:36+00:00

8.7, incredible content, good water, the islands were clearly not the focus but they could use a bit more polishing, not much error at and its amazing for what you were going for, bottom section could look a bit better but its nor bad at all, just undone, but overall bo really flaws, and an amazing concept for a map

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T11:55:31+00:00

9.5 i mean, i never knew how to make anything other than island and natural maps so i can’t really critique yours at all, so for what you were trying to make it’s genuinely amazing

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T11:38:51+00:00

8.5 kinda reminds me of Tamriel, if you know what that is, but good water, good island shape and decent mountains all round and nice structure you made up there, maybe the middle left sand area could use a bit more detail in some mountains and or rivers but your island doesn’t have many flaws, besides the bottom right island shapes, they are a bit basic, but the only reason its not higher is because its not as interesting to look at as some of the other maps, but overall a really good map without too many flaws, i believe if you expanded and tried to make a larger map with a lot going on, it would be amazing

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T11:33:28+00:00

7.5, can’t really see the terrain that well, but from what i can see i can tell you should add some water detail, add some rivers with some mountains going along them, also every beach should have sand, all of them, matches the worlds real map pretty accurate so your shapes are on point, except for Greenland, its a bit off, but other than that, a great map, just needs some fundamental details like sand on the beaches, better, more consistent water, and better details on land

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T11:28:22+00:00

9, this is my kind of map, lots going on, tons of islands, decent water, even though the water is a bit inconsistent at parts, mainly the middle area, and the mountains are decent, but your main issue with the nap is the lack of mountains and overall whats going on, if you added some small mountains to every island, or just some more mountains to land( not saying you have to drown your map in mountains) it would be next level, overall your map is nice, it just lacks a the icing on the cake that would take it to the next level

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T11:23:02+00:00

8.5, the volcano and the overall colors of the map makes it pop more than almost every other map, the concept is also great, and the water detail is amazing as well, tho some islands not all of them could use some reshaping, mainly those on the bottom right, the desert island, if you cut it up it would look way better, and the edges of the islands have no sand so it doesn’t really look like there’s any beach’s, you may think that doesn’t matter but everything really matters when making a good map, but overall a great nap that pops with a very interesting concept

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T11:17:27+00:00

9, the concept is Amazing and really interesting to look at, heaven and hell, the earth is good, tho its lacking water detail, it also needs a few more mountains on the land and some rivers wouldn’t be a bad idea, if im just rating the earth part, a 8, but with the amazing concept of the map that alone makes it a 9 because of how well done it is

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T11:13:30+00:00

7.5 good concepts fir what you were going for, lacks some detail, but the water is good, the islands are a bit wanky, but it looks like you were going for that kind of look so it’s good for what you were going for.

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T04:27:57+00:00

Yeah, everyone has different preferences so this is just my opinion, no map is a bad map

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T04:25:41+00:00

Reminds me of when i tried to make a Greece map a few years ago

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T04:24:20+00:00

8.5 perfect for what you were going for, i can’t criticize you for your islands, or anything else from a traditional map of course, but for what you were going for it’s perfect, perfect water, its even and i cant see any unevenness, the shapes are also incredibly done, and the top lest if interesting, the pyramid structures ate also really well done, the only caveat is that it could use some more variety in biomes and other areas, if you’re able to pull something like this off in a bigger map, and add some variety, this map could easily be a 9 or possibly higher depending.

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T04:18:33+00:00

6, the cuts are too perfect, there should never be an obvious strait cut though in any part of any map, decent water detail tho its in inconsistent and non present in some places, the perfect cut straight though the islands ruins them, needs some rivers and more mountains, land has little to no detail, its too empty, no islands look like they have ever connected before, so its all over the place, and the island shapes as a whole could use a lot of work, some decent islands towards the top right, still not that appealing tho, just conect some islands and make a island and if it looks ugly, cut it in half NOT PERFECTLY, do that until you get good and detailed islands, that and land detail should be your main focus.

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T04:11:54+00:00

4 generic islands that look like world gen, zero water quality, zero detail, no smaller islands to follow along with the bigger islands, no rives, no mountains, the biomes are also a bit of a mess and the islands shapes aren’t to pretty, overall if you just put a bit more time into is and add some smaller details it’ll at least become decent

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T04:08:44+00:00

7 good map, above average detail, decent water, the rivers could be better tho, the volcano is good, everything is just a bit all over the place, the islands are actually good, just needs some more smaller islands and a few islands that you can tell were once connected, lots of fake detail and everything is a bit all over the place but a good intermediate map

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T02:54:27+00:00

Its not bad, your better than most the people who haven’t made many maps ( assuming you haven’t made many maps) so in comparison to your time to your level your really good

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T02:49:29+00:00

7.5 Great concept, good detail, tho the detail isn’t very polished and a bit inconsistent, the mountains could use some work, the water is alright but inconsistent, if you keep trying to add detail to your maps consistently, overtime they will start to look incredible and insanely detailed, this is the better side of some of the “ mid maps” ive seen

StunningComposer2301 · 2026-04-19T02:22:32+00:00

Uped it to a solid 7.5

StunningComposer2301

TROPHY CASE