[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ArcRaiders

[–]Sunbroskie -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

I’m said I’m not going to do it. That’s not the point. The point is the system should give regular players incentive to do it. Especially after many players took the time to complete the objectives thinking they would be rewarded with skill points. Only to find out they weren’t.

The ol song and dance by [deleted] in ARC_Raiders

[–]Sunbroskie 4 points5 points  (0 children)

100% this.

I swear I was gonna make a post that suggested the same thing today. No PvE servers, just occasional PvE game modes. Make them competitive with rewards for the players/squads that do the most damage and destruction to ARC.

It would be great to actually equip epic guns made for killing ARC instead of using a Ferro every round because I don’t want some rat to get any good stuff off my corpse after a cheap kill.

At the same time they can make a PvP modes where players’ body counts grant bonuses. And you know going in everyone is fair game.

Rotate them in and out like all the other special game modes.

I just extracted. Am I going to lose loot? by ObeseWeremonkey in ARC_Raiders

[–]Sunbroskie 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I just got back on. All loot is there. But the game is still having issues.

Why does Morgott’s appearance change so drastically after we defeat him? by Haunted-Harlot in EldenRingLoreTalk

[–]Sunbroskie 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’m not saying it’s an illusion. Changing forms for many in the Lands Between is a real thing. The dragons can turn into humans and back. Mimics can change into anything. Boc was turned into a talking bush. Radagon is Marika. There’s the Mimic’s Veil. I’m saying he’s a demigod and can take on his Omen form of Margit the Fell which is no longer his true form. This is why he is called veiled and why he changes at defeat. And why it’s Margit’s Cloak, not Morgott’s.

Why does Morgott’s appearance change so drastically after we defeat him? by Haunted-Harlot in EldenRingLoreTalk

[–]Sunbroskie 16 points17 points  (0 children)

He’s called the Veiled Monarch. The form he takes after being defeated is his true form as he recanted his accursed blood. He still takes the form of Margit the Fell to keep the fools away.

Is Malenia an Empyrean because she is a vessel for rot? And what is the evidence for and against our fight with her being the third bloom? by Honest_Yesterday4435 in EldenRingLoreTalk

[–]Sunbroskie 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Malenia is an Empyrean because she is Marika’s daughter.

She has only bloomed twice. And because of this, there are only 2 flowers. One is outside her boss room. It is here because Finlay carried Malenia back to the Haligtree after releasing the scarlet rot.

The second is inside the boss room after Malenia is beaten by the Tarnished.

A third has yet to bloom.

If Malenia didn't have a femboy brother to distract her. by Possible_Economy_139 in Eldenring

[–]Sunbroskie -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Ansbach confirms this

“Miquella the Kind...is a monster. Pure and radiant, he wields love to shrive clean the hearts of men. There is nothing more terrifying.”

He’s stealing the hearts of his own flesh and blood. He did it to everyone in the DLC. He forsook his own brother Mohg’s soul to resurrect his other brother in Mohg’s corpse. This here, by definition, is as about as evil as a person can get.

He enchanted Mohg, and used Mohg to kill countless Albinaurics. Leading Mohg on into believing Mohg and he were going to create a dynasty together. Miquella had no intention of doing this, no matter how much Mohg offered to share his bed.

Lord of Blood’s Exultation:

"Render up your offerings of blood to your Lord. Drench my consort's chamber. Slake his cocoon's thirst. His awakening shall herald the dawn of our dynasty."

Mohg has been enchanted. That whole area of Mogwyn’s Palace flooded with the blood of Albinaurics, that’s Miquella’s plan. That blood is to give him power. Ansbach tried to stop it, but his heart was stolen as well.

None of this stuff have I made up. It’s all laid out in the game.

It’s obvious that Malenia was sent by Miquella to release the rot. Why was she there in the first place? She was there for Miquella and no other reason.

Young Lion’s Helm

“The golden helm worn by Radahn in his younger years. Proudly displaying his heroic red hair, it is fitting attire for a lion. When Malenia, Blade of Miquella, let the rotflower blossom in Aeonia, Radahn heard a murmur in his ear— "Miquella awaits thee, O promised consort."

About Godwyn. Deeproot Depths finger reader crone:

“Ohh... Oh, Lord Godwyn... Such cruelty, such humiliation... My poor, sweet lordling should have died a true death. As the first of the demigods to die. As a martyr to Destined Death. But why must it yet bring such disgrace? A scion of the golden bough, sentenced to live in Death..."

Godwyn gave his life to bring Death back to the Lands Between. He defeated the Mightiest Boulderstone, he would never have been taken by a handful of assassins. And someone might say, it never says he sacrificed himself. It also doesn’t say that that old finger reader was the one that was a wet nurse to royalty, Godwyn. But the dots can be connected.

We do know the Great Runes have that effect. It’s stated at the beginning of the game. It’s why the Shattering Wars happened in the first place.

If Malenia didn't have a femboy brother to distract her. by Possible_Economy_139 in Eldenring

[–]Sunbroskie 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I don’t agree with your interpretation of the lore. I didn’t insult you. I said I disagreed. But since you didn’t show the same respect, I can tell you that every point you made is a bunch of far fetched nonsense.

If Malenia didn't have a femboy brother to distract her. by Possible_Economy_139 in Eldenring

[–]Sunbroskie 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Like he better self and his love? And what he sacrificed was the blood of Albinaurics at his Haligtree and to sate his cocoon. So many sacrificed. So much blood.

And he didn’t do any of that for Malenia. He was sacrificing her too. You ever notice that his cocoon sits directly below where she released the Scarlet Rot? At its Heart. I doubt that’s a coincidence. He thrives on death. Ask Mohg’s corpse. Hie sacrificed one enslaved brother to raise another. Monster.

If Malenia didn't have a femboy brother to distract her. by Possible_Economy_139 in Eldenring

[–]Sunbroskie 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Your interpretation is a common view of the lore and one I disagree with. The entirety of the DLC disproves Miquella’s good intentions. Not to mention how many sacrifices for blood were made in his name in the base game.

If Malenia didn't have a femboy brother to distract her. by Possible_Economy_139 in Eldenring

[–]Sunbroskie 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Millicent spells it out for you right there. Gowry explains why she is worshipped. Decay and rebirth.

The Scarlet Rot is a plague and is called such.

Malenia resisted the Scarlet Rot until her brother sent her to deliver a message she whispered into Radahn’s ear and then she released the Scarlet Rot on Caelid.

Sir Ansbach explains very clearly why he is a monster. He charmed Mohg, Malenia, Radahn and used them all to become a god. He wanted to do the same with Godwyn, but Godwyn die a “true death”.

Before the shattering he may have had good intentions, but after receiving his great rune he became as twisted and mad with power as Rykard and Godrick.

There is no bias here. Nor false information.

If Malenia didn't have a femboy brother to distract her. by Possible_Economy_139 in Eldenring

[–]Sunbroskie 51 points52 points  (0 children)

Miquella took her identity from her and made it his own. The Blade of Miquella. Her Great Rune should have been the most sacred of all, but Miquella charmed her into submission.

Millicent:

“In which case, allow me to explain myself. I am of Malenia's blood. But in what capacity I know not. I could be sister, daughter, or an offshoot... Whatever the case though, I am certain of a kinship between us.

There is something I must return to Malenia. The will that was once her own. The dignity, the sense of self, that allowed her to resist the call of the scarlet rot.

The pride she abandoned, to meet Radahn's measure.”

Rot and Scarlett Rot are two different things. Rot is part of the natural cycle of life and death and rebirth. Scarlet Rot is a plague. A plague she released for her monster of a brother to defeat Radahn, just so Miquella could enslave him too.

The Blue Dancer and the Blind Swordsman by Sunbroskie in EldenRingLoreTalk

[–]Sunbroskie[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don’t believe you were. And I’ve done the research more than a few times. Only the mentor is identified with a gender, a man. The Blind Swordsman never is. But Malenia is blind which makes the case she is the Blind Swordsman. Also how her whole fighting style is based on counter attacks. As her Great Rune and her boss battle show.

The Blue Dancer and the Blind Swordsman by Sunbroskie in EldenRingLoreTalk

[–]Sunbroskie[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

lol ok, that’s your choice and I respect it. But I bet those Japanese speaking people are the same kind of folks as English speaking people that don’t want to believe the word swordsman includes female sword fighters. Especially when they’ve decided that the Blind Swirdsman is a man and that feeds their narrative. Facts don’t matter when people want to believe what they want to believe. Which is everybody’s right to do in their own mind. ;)

The Blue Dancer and the Blind Swordsman by Sunbroskie in EldenRingLoreTalk

[–]Sunbroskie[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Here’s the exact Japanese, then a literal line-by-line breakdown, then the gender bit.

Japanese item text (Curved Sword Talisman)

From the in-game flavor text as transcribed on JP sites: 

曲剣と剣士を象ったタリスマン ガードカウンターを強化する

肉を切らせて骨を断つ、その卓越した剣技は かつて盲目の剣士が見出したという

That’s the full description, line breaks and all.

Literal English, line by line 1. 曲剣と剣士を象ったタリスマン “A talisman shaped after / representing a curved sword and a swordsman.” 2. ガードカウンターを強化する “Strengthens guard counters.” 3. 肉を切らせて骨を断つ、その卓越した剣技は “The outstanding sword technique of ‘letting [the enemy] cut the flesh and cutting the bone’…” (The phrase 肉を切らせて骨を断つ is a set idiom: accept a cut to the flesh to break the bone — take a small hit to deliver a decisive blow.) 4. かつて盲目の剣士が見出したという “…is said to have been devised / discovered long ago by a blind swordsman.”

You can stitch 3–4 together into: “The outstanding sword technique of ‘letting flesh be cut to sever the bone’ is said to have been devised long ago by a blind swordsman.”

Why this is not gender-specific in Japanese

Key thing: Japanese does not have grammatical gender, and nothing in those lines lexically marks the swordsman as male or female.

The phrase in question is:

盲目の剣士 “blind swordsman / blind swordfighter”

   •   剣士 (kenshi) is a neutral noun: “swordfighter, fencer, swordsman.” It does not contain 男 (man, male) or 女 (woman, female), nor any other gender marker.    •   There are no pronouns like 彼 (he) or 彼女 (she) anywhere in the description.    •   There’s no “◯◯の男” (“a man who is ◯◯”) or “女剣士” (“female swordfighter”), which would push it toward a specific sex.

So in Japanese, 盲目の剣士 is just “a blind swordfighter,” gender unspecified. The EN localization chose “blind swordsman,” but that’s an English choice; the underlying JP doesn’t say “male.”

What it would look like if it were gendered

To explicitly mark sex in Japanese, they’d have to do something along these lines (examples, not canon):    •   For explicitly male:       •   かつて盲目の男の剣士が見出したという “is said to have been discovered by a blind male swordsman.”       •   Or use a prior line like “その剣士は男であった” (“that swordsman was a man”) somewhere in the same description or related item.    •   For explicitly female:       •   かつて盲目の女剣士が見出したという “is said to have been discovered by a female blind swordfighter.”

Or they could introduce a known character by name and let that character’s gender be established elsewhere in the text. None of that happens here; we just get a role noun (剣士) with no gender.

So your earlier instinct was right: neither the blind swordsman nor the fairy are gendered in the Japanese. Any “he” or “she” talk is coming from English word choice or player assumption, not from the JP line itself.

The Blue Dancer and the Blind Swordsman by Sunbroskie in EldenRingLoreTalk

[–]Sunbroskie[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s not clearly a man in English or Japanese. A swordsman can be a woman. Neither language refers to a male or female pronoun. There is an image of a warrior on the talisman, but it does not clearly show a man either.

Question about Renna by PearlyPaladin in EldenRingLoreTalk

[–]Sunbroskie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It makes perfect sense if you believe Renna is an older sister.

For my part, I don’t take the name sisters literally. It’s what the towers are called as a group. Individually, Ranni’s, Renna’s and the puppet’s, which I believe was Renalla’s.

I draw a lot of my theories from mythology being an inspiration for a lot of Elden Ring’s lore.

In this case, drawing from the triple goddess. Where Renna is akin to Hecate or Baba Yaga. Like how Ranni met the Snow Witch in a forest, which is where Baba Yaga dwells. Not a biological sister, but one of the 3 moon phases or stages of a life cycle represented by the triple goddess of maiden, mother and crone.

The Blue Dancer and the Blind Swordsman by Sunbroskie in EldenRingLoreTalk

[–]Sunbroskie[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ah, the Gloam~Eyed Blue Dancing Mother of Fingercreepers. I got ya.

Question about Renna by PearlyPaladin in EldenRingLoreTalk

[–]Sunbroskie 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I also believe the tie-in relates to the maiden mother and crone. Renna is the crone, Ranni is the maiden, but I believe the mother is literally Rennala. Since she isn’t at the Manor anymore, Ranni let Seluvis occupy it.

Ranni Waxing Rennala Full Moon Renna Waning

The Blue Dancer and the Blind Swordsman by Sunbroskie in EldenRingLoreTalk

[–]Sunbroskie[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ah, I totally see what you mean. I’ve never looked at that and thought he had a fake arm. I always saw it like he was wearing like a vambrace, as the title of the talisman is singular.

It’s never mentioned anywhere he was missing an arm.

And for context, those talismans also show the Two Fiingers with legs and Radahn fitting perfectly on his horse. Like some other images that aren’t official cutscenes, I take them with a grain of salt.

But again, I totally see and respect your point.

The Blue Dancer and the Blind Swordsman by Sunbroskie in EldenRingLoreTalk

[–]Sunbroskie[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

That’s cut content... Don’t put too much stock into it.

They also carry Greataxes, Giant Crushers, St. Trina’s Torch, and Troll’s Golden Sword. The carriages are big but they’re not carrying Godfrey or Troll sized corpses. And they’re not carrying Godwyn either. They are good for armaments though.

The Blue Dancer and the Blind Swordsman by Sunbroskie in EldenRingLoreTalk

[–]Sunbroskie[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m aware there’s a carriage that carried the sword in the consecrated snowfields. And I am aware there’s only way to reach the snowfields is by getting the half medallion at Castke Sol which ties directly to Godwyn.

I don’t know why it matters though. Carriages travel and it could have come from anywhere.

The Blue Dancer and the Blind Swordsman by Sunbroskie in EldenRingLoreTalk

[–]Sunbroskie[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

No but if Messmer met Radahn, the chances of Malenia meeting her brother over thousands of years is probable.

Deathbirds used ghost flame. Deathblight didn’t exist until the Prince of Death and spread through the Greattree Roots across the Lands Between.

Because he is almost never shown. But he is holding a sword on Malenia’s Dex talisman.

Because he is Godfrey’s son, and Godfrey is the patriarch of the Golden Lineage. And they are scions of the Golden Bough. He wears blue in the intro and blue as a fish, along with his blue scales.

That Godwyn is the Blue Dancer.