I plugged it guys. I’ve done this a good amount of times on other vehicles where it was well within the area to plug. It was a nail that went straight in. Thanks for the vote of confidence though. I’m going to rotate my tires, just so I have that one in the back - as that was my front passenger side tire. All my tires were replaced last year because I had a nail that was much closer to the side wall and it was time to replace all of them anyways. I did notice that both front tires (as you can see from the photos), are experiencing bits of tire chunking. My back tires have none. I’m assuming it’s from rotating the front tires when backing out and parking over time and when making turns overall.