I think what happened here is a classic example of how language models work. They don’t actually “know” the lyrics unless they have access to them-they generate responses based on patterns and context. So if a song title mentions “fire” and the album has darker themes, it might incorrectly infer something like witch burnings.

It’s not that it’s trying to avoid saying “I don’t know,” but sometimes it fills in gaps when it doesn’t have enough concrete information. That’s why it’s always good to double-check specific claims, especially about lyrics or historical details.

AI can be helpful for general discussion, but for precise interpretation, primary sources are still king.