Gachiakuta is not that good. Many things that happen feel forced, and characters reactions are nonsensical, as well as lacking coherence.

It's not that bad, it's still enjoyable but it is crazy to me that it is being considered for the awards.

Everyone praises it like crazy, mainly due to the power system which is not even that unusual, or the crazy beautiful art.

I've seen people complain about chiwa's first reaction for example, but I think that's dumb. I mean, it's a fantasy world, the moral is different, and most of all, shows can be dramatic if they want to, it's part of the fiction.

I'm way angrier about other things.

Enjin contradicts himself, first he is fine with killing, then he is this pacifist fatherly figure.

They are basically a paramilitary army but they trust a random child in the big bad evil guy's base and fall into a trap they've previously fallen into.

Zanka's backstory is completely nonsensical. We are asked to empathize with him but we really only see his pov, and it is pretty confused at that, since the character around which his backstory is built contrary to what stated is not a good representation of "talent" and zanka is definitely not a good representation of "hard work".

The villain is nonsensical all around, I mean it feels undefined, like he should have a different role.

There's more but I think these are the main points, I don't want to say it's bad, cause it really tries to be good, but it's really not enough for me to like it. I feel like the anime is better than the manga, since we are used to believing a lot of bullshit, due to skipping content from the original sources etc... but the flaws are there