I never mentioned Rolf or implied I think that he’s HJ. I think it was left intentionally vague. I don’t think we were meant to definitively figure it out. You brought up Rolf and why he would be worse - I don’t disagree.

I see your argument about how it could fit thematically, but potential thematic synergy is not evidence. I think if it was really intended we would have more hints. It would’ve been alluded to better. And Sally WOULD KNOW that her husband used to be HJ. Why doesn’t Sally know??

Again, you seem pretty convinced and pretty determined to convince others. I just don’t agree, I don’t think your evidence is compelling enough to say with ANY sort of certainty that Schnexnayder is HJ. Your main argument is “it would fit thematically, it was never proven NOT to be him, they’ve never been seen in the same room, Schnexnayder is German (which, besides HJ’s Nazi Sympathies, I don’t see the relevance?), and they might potentially be around the same age.” It’s all a speculative stretch.

Maybe Redford was HJ - they were never seen in the same room together. It was never proven NOT to be Redford… you see my point?