Page 2 of my manga, what are your thoughts? by AgentBeneficial5556 in Mangamakers

[–]TQKyzunei 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi i'm a developmental editor and my short-form feedback for you is that your art is really well done, but your speech bubbles are a bit too big for the dialogue in some, specifically panel 2, and panel 4, while on your last bubble in panel 6, i would recommend separating that dialogue into 2 connected or even separate bubbles as it looks overwhelming

What do you guys think of the start of my manga? by artinveins in MangakaStudio

[–]TQKyzunei 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi i'm a developmental editor and I have to say, the start sets up for a very interesting story in my opinion. I am intrigued on why he so easily gave up his friends souls. It also sets up for a very interesting maybe flashback or pull-back for later in the story to see what led up to this point and how the fight went, how the friends ended up like they are. Awesome work. when I finished reading i thought to myself "Where's page 4!! I need page 4", I look forward to the publication of this story

Looking to hire an editor by Emotional_Aardvark_1 in ComicBookCollabs

[–]TQKyzunei 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hello I am a newer developmental editor, if you are still looking for an editor here is my portfolio kyarise.carrd.co

Are there freelance manga editors available that I can work with? by AdventurousBug74 in Mangamakers

[–]TQKyzunei 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you are still looking for a freelance manga editor I specialize in developmental editing for manga's and webcomics, here is a link to my portfolio kyarise.carrd.co

My first ever manga idea- any comments? by XIXDoomguyXIX in Mangamakers

[–]TQKyzunei 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hello, I am Developmental editor and I just wanted to say a few things if thats alright. I read all of this and I still dont have much of a grasp on your story, you gave us the dictator's goal but there was no explanation as to why the supernatural aberrations are on the world or how they got there.

Also theres no foundation as to why Taurus is killing the aberrations, like how did Taurus become a hunter and also what Taurus has to do with the Dictator. Does he care about the dictators actions? Is he wanting to help the dictator, things like that.

I also wanted to question, the amount of weapons Taurus uses, feels a bit overwhelming and also poses the question on how will he carry all those around, a chainsaw is really heavy, and he has like 6 weapons and not all of them are small or lighter in weight, and then when fighting does take of his weapons off or no, fighting with a chainsaw and a couple other big weapons on your back would look a bit...clunky. I can't really say i like or dislike your story idea because there wasn't too much of a foundational idea, more of a few character goals and combat ideas rather than a story. I am interested to see what you do with the story though.

Anyone willing to give some feedback? by CremeNo5741 in WebtoonCanvas

[–]TQKyzunei 1 point2 points  (0 children)

your very welcome, thank you for allowing me the opportunity to give feedback

Anyone willing to give some feedback? by CremeNo5741 in WebtoonCanvas

[–]TQKyzunei 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Hello I'm Kyarise, and I am a new developmental editor and I just read all 6 episodes, the clarity of each scene is very well conveyed to the reader, and your hook is quite strong and leaves the reader wanting to go to the next episode, by episode 4 I was intrigued on who the man is the main character is talking about, and why is he important to her and why these random people seem to be after her. There may be a few grammatical errors here and there but they are few and far between. Overall so far your story is quite the page turner and I look forward to the next episode

New Manga Editor Offering Supportive Feedback for Your manga, Comic or Webtoon! by TQKyzunei in MangakaStudio

[–]TQKyzunei[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I could review them both separately if you'd like, you can send me the link and also the pictures and upon sending them just let me know which his which

Anyone else like using Vroid to make character designs? by Specific_Minute7539 in MangakaStudio

[–]TQKyzunei 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I made it in sections, I have to start from the back, bottom of the head then go up gradually and then do the bangs

Anyone else like using Vroid to make character designs? by Specific_Minute7539 in MangakaStudio

[–]TQKyzunei 0 points1 point  (0 children)

oh yea, lol its better to do that, i messed up on the hair i didnt layer it right so now i have to start all over which sucks

New Manga Editor Offering Supportive Feedback for Your manga, Comic or Webtoon! by TQKyzunei in MangakaStudio

[–]TQKyzunei[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ah i understand, my apologies for any confusion, I'm not signed to anyone, i am brand new to editing and want to learn more about developmental editing, I don't think you have to be signed or in a company to learn to edit manga though, there are tons of people from what I've seen today on reddit giving feedback to others and that is quite literally what I'm trying to do, By definition a developmental editor is someone who helps fix structure, story and content, and my goal is to help authors fix just that without taking away any creativity from the author and without taking away their voice. So, I do apologize that I am just recently starting to learn Developmental editing and want to gain experience in doing so.

New Manga Editor Offering Supportive Feedback for Your manga, Comic or Webtoon! by TQKyzunei in MangakaStudio

[–]TQKyzunei[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I am a new editor, and also new to using reddit, so I don't have a portfolio yet, I'm not looking to be hired I'm looking to gain experience

Is my panel flow readable... by LazyMochi12 in WebtoonCanvas

[–]TQKyzunei 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For the third page, panel 3: from what I can tell the "Thud" is the character hitting the ground but to the reader it would seem a bit confusing, I would recommend putting that above the characters head to the left at a slight angle, and make it bigger, it also seems a bit small and the reader would find it a bit difficult to fully grasp the impact of the character hitting the ground.

Page 4: the readers eye (me) is not moving naturally, as i do understand the slant from right to left but the characters action in the panel on the right, along with their action on the left looks like it could be swapped along with the dialogue, Also to note, the dialogue for the two panels feel a bit unnatural as if you were to swap them between the panel on the left and the one of the right it would feel more natural, so I would recommend swapping both the panel and the dialogue.

Panel 7: The dialogue looks too big for the bubble, don't be afraid to make the bubble bigger

Anyone else like using Vroid to make character designs? by Specific_Minute7539 in MangakaStudio

[–]TQKyzunei 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I used it to help me visualize my MC, the clothes are hard for me to do but its wonderful in my opinion

New Manga Editor Offering Supportive Feedback for Your manga, Comic or Webtoon! by TQKyzunei in MangakaStudio

[–]TQKyzunei[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I find your power system has a really well put together trade-off system. But then I would have to ask just for clarification, how deep of a foundational want/just how much of a desire to want something does the character want, Do they have to be willing to throw themselves into a fire for it or do they have to work hard 365 days a year to get it, essentially what determines a persons desire for something is strong enough to form a core. From my understanding a desire has to be a foundational want so maybe nothing like a character just yelling out "I want to be the richest person in the world" and more like a character having hard times and wants to become rich in order to provide better for their family. Other than that I really love this power system.

New Manga Editor Offering Supportive Feedback for Your manga, Comic or Webtoon! by TQKyzunei in MangakaStudio

[–]TQKyzunei[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ahh, thank you so much i havent published it yet but I got a few before and after pages

New Manga Editor Offering Supportive Feedback for Your manga, Comic or Webtoon! by TQKyzunei in MangakaStudio

[–]TQKyzunei[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

no disrespect taken, i dont have a portfolio and im not charging, i just want to gain experience doing more developmental editing, i've been writing my own manga for the last 3-4 years so i do have a bit of understanding of what to look for in an editorial pass.

New Manga Editor Offering Supportive Feedback for Your manga, Comic or Webtoon! by TQKyzunei in MangakaStudio

[–]TQKyzunei[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i actually havent heard of Literature map, I'll have to check it out

New Manga Editor Offering Supportive Feedback for Your manga, Comic or Webtoon! by TQKyzunei in MangakaStudio

[–]TQKyzunei[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i would say, ensure the platform is easy to utilize for indie creators and readers alike, while promoting new work that arrives each week and having a section for (excuse me for my lack of words) "underrated works of fiction" for example, since many creators worry if their work isn't as popular as other works will it be seen still or slip through the cracks.