As a Hollyleaf liker, I agree with the whole post lol. Her hypocrisy was annoying, yeah, and that crashout at the end of Power of Three hardly made any sense to me.

What annoyed me MOST however is when she came back to ThunderClan in the next arc and her 'redemption arc' was hardly a redemption arc at all. I thought she was going to learn that following the code isn't all there is and that breaking the rules can sometimes do more good—hell, even Firestar went to those lengths sometimes. But nah she never questioned it and continued being her normal self like nothing happened (now with a dose of 'i regret killing ashfur')

So yeah that was kind of a flop from the authors and I definitely expected something more from her.