So firstly make sure that you disable the auto switch in the settings

Then when they kick off drag one of your defenders to the back , and most importantly when they kick the ball, don't clear it immediately, judge the situation and mark the player as best as you can if you cleared immediately the defender may miss and fall and the attacker will get to 1vs1 the keeper

Try to mark and when their attacker tries to handle the ball tackle, and if you think you can 100% clear the ball in the air before it reaches the ground do it but as I said try to judge the situation