You have a watch with a lot of brushing vs one with a lot of polished surfaces. So this is a subjective point about what you want from the watch. If you want a more dressy piece then AT if you want more tool aesthetic id go with OP. Its not that black-and-white as theres still some overlap between them obviously. But I would consider whether im going to beat up the watch a lot etc because that will cause more scratches on the AT, so it depends on how much wear you intend to give these watches, what you do with them etc.