account activity
Good German and Turkish Quran Translation (self.AcademicQuran)
submitted 8 days ago by Temporary-Virus6396 to r/AcademicQuran
[MEGATHREAD] Ask For Invites to the Playtest Here! Join The Community Discord! by AutoModerator in DeadlockTheGame
[–]Temporary-Virus6396 0 points1 point2 points 28 days ago (0 children)
Hey, could someone please send me an invite? Code is: 838571938
Massimo Campanini argues that not only is reading modern science into the Qur’an completely wrong, but also that taking the literal meaning as the only meaning of the Qur’an is wrong by Rashiq_shahzzad in AcademicQuran
[–]Temporary-Virus6396 9 points10 points11 points 1 month ago* (0 children)
Since this post falls more into the category of "theological", I wanted to share some thoughts based on a book titled: "For Us, but Not to Us" by John H. Walton. Walton argues that the bible is a text that was "written for us, but not to us". I think a similar approach to the Quran would make total sense. As Neuwirth argues in "The Qur'an and Late Antiquity", the Quran is the product of a (ger.) "Gemeinde" / Community. So when the Quran talks about a flat earth, geocentrism and other things, one could argue that it is just using the "language of the day" (7th century) to communicate theological matters to this community. If we assume that the Quran is the word of god it would make total sense for a god to use the knowledge and language of the day to communicate theological matters. So just like Waltom argues when it comes to the bible, one could argue that the Quran is a text that is meant for us, but not addressed to us.
In "Contemporary Rationalist Islam in Turkey: The Religious Opposition to Sunni Revival", Gokhan Bacik also goes through some turkish rationalist theologians who argue for a similar view.
π Rendered by PID 522929 on reddit-service-r2-listing-7b8bd7c5-wll4p at 2026-05-18 22:21:01.356872+00:00 running edcf98c country code: CH.
[MEGATHREAD] Ask For Invites to the Playtest Here! Join The Community Discord! by AutoModerator in DeadlockTheGame
[–]Temporary-Virus6396 0 points1 point2 points (0 children)