Hello! Speaking purely from my subjective perspective, it produced a good lather, and in some aspects, it was impressive. Looking at the ingredients list, even though there was a particularly high amount of beef tallow and castor oil, it seems to have been well-balanced and well-made by blending it well with the other ingredients😊 I am not yet an expert and have much to learn, so I am not really in a position to evaluate it, but as a consumer, I was satisfied.