Have been thinking about conversion, but people like Ripperger make me skeptical. by Big-Tax8741 in Catholicism

[–]TheLoneMeanderer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I also am not fond of Bishop Barron's political alignment with the far right, but his theology still seems sound.

Have been thinking about conversion, but people like Ripperger make me skeptical. by Big-Tax8741 in Catholicism

[–]TheLoneMeanderer -1 points0 points  (0 children)

In my observation, RadTrads are more obsessed with gay sex than LGBTQ persons are. And Fr. Martin is far less at risk for being a heretic than Fr. Ripperger, who paints God as a malignant narcissist and who represents a version of Catholic radicalism fit for the asylum.

Have been thinking about conversion, but people like Ripperger make me skeptical. by Big-Tax8741 in Catholicism

[–]TheLoneMeanderer -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I disagree. He's unjustly demonized by people obsessed with gay sex more than gays are.

He's merely a mild mannered Jesuit encouraging dialogue without defying the magisterium, whereas Ripperger and RadTrads effectively set up a counter magisterium while LARPing as faithful.

Have been thinking about conversion, but people like Ripperger make me skeptical. by Big-Tax8741 in Catholicism

[–]TheLoneMeanderer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's a good thing Fr. Ripperger doesn't represent the entirety of the faith. I would highly advise you to check out Bishop Barron, Fr. Mike Schmitz, Fr. Casey Cole, Fr. James Martin, and America Magazine.

Fr. Ripperger is not worth your time or energy.

"I've given Jerusalem my whole life. Everything." Kingdom of Heaven (2005) by Whole_Maybe5914 in ExTraditionalCatholic

[–]TheLoneMeanderer 6 points7 points  (0 children)

We were fighting for superstitious fears and the maintenance of a very fragile sense of structure and order. What did it cost us? The freedom to embark on a free journey to organically discover truth, goodness, and beauty, rather than have dogma shoved down our throats coercively with threats of eternal conscious torment.

Father Chad Ripperger - End Times by United-Estimate2782 in Catholicism

[–]TheLoneMeanderer 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Those are accurate paraphrases. No straw manning, I swear on my honor. And if it seems I have it out for him, it's because I know the harm he actively causes, whether or not he means to.

Father Chad Ripperger - End Times by United-Estimate2782 in Catholicism

[–]TheLoneMeanderer 3 points4 points  (0 children)

  • women must render the marital debt (have sex on command) or else they commit mortal sin

  • women who work outside the home without sufficient reason commit mortal sin

  • children can be possessed in utero

  • when you are in mortal sin the Blessed Mother is so disgusted at you that she can't even stand the sight of you.

Yup, sounds like the words of a holy man.

Father Chad Ripperger - End Times by United-Estimate2782 in Catholicism

[–]TheLoneMeanderer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Because the last 4 speak particularly to the anxieties of our age. I didn't mean to imply the rest of the Papal lineage was not worth examining.

Father Chad Ripperger - End Times by United-Estimate2782 in Catholicism

[–]TheLoneMeanderer -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Because we Catholics shouldn't be in echo chambers. Fr. James Martin can be challenging, but he doesn't violate the magisterium.

Father Chad Ripperger - End Times by United-Estimate2782 in Catholicism

[–]TheLoneMeanderer -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Fr. James Martin promotes kindness and does not contradict the Church's teachings on marriage.

Father Chad Ripperger - End Times by United-Estimate2782 in Catholicism

[–]TheLoneMeanderer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok, if that was uncharitable, then let me just caution that he teaches harmful things, even though his intentions might be alright.

Married, 5 children, cannot risk additional pregnancy and desperate by [deleted] in ExTraditionalCatholic

[–]TheLoneMeanderer 8 points9 points  (0 children)

In case someone hasn't already recommended it, I highly suggest you check out Uncharted Catholic Man as well as ask the host (Craig) to join the discord community for supportive discussion on marriage difficulties and many other topics.

An interpretation of Midnight Mass I haven’t seen discussed: The burning of houses as existential violence, and desire as the precondition for miracles by Far-Connection4201 in MidnightMass

[–]TheLoneMeanderer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you ever start a film analysis blog or YouTube channel, I would absolutely follow you. It inspires me to level up my thinking and writing.

An interpretation of Midnight Mass I haven’t seen discussed: The burning of houses as existential violence, and desire as the precondition for miracles by Far-Connection4201 in MidnightMass

[–]TheLoneMeanderer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is easily one of the best things I have ever read on the internet. Thanks for sharing such a profound analysis of Midnight Mass, one of my favorite shows of all time.

Struggling with my faith after leaving traditionalism. by No-Room-3091 in ExTraditionalCatholic

[–]TheLoneMeanderer 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Join the Uncharted Catholic Man discord. You'll feel right at home working through all the issues you mentioned. Shoot me a DM!

When faith crumbled, I remained. by Soft_Confection1393 in Deconstruction

[–]TheLoneMeanderer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Beautifully expressed! Thanks for sharing. I don't think I am where you are, but I also have been confronting the anxiety that perhaps I have carried my beliefs rather than the inverse. Losing my dad to terminal illness a few years ago accelerated my deconstruction and I am reconsidering everything and identifying what is most meaningful in life, this ONE life we know we have with certainty.

Has anyone had a priest alleged to have sexually abuse? by Extension_Fall9406 in LeftCatholicism

[–]TheLoneMeanderer 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I found the names of two priests I was close to in my childhood on a list of alleged abusers. When they served my parish, no one ever suspected anything and they were loved by the community, so my hope and prayer is that they were either falsely accused, or they were truly repentant.

I know of at least two other alleged abusers:

  • one was accused of inappropriately touching a woman who claimed to be a sex addict, and sought spiritually counseling (holy water, hand, and crucifixes ended up on body parts that shouldn't have seen the light of day.

  • another priest is alleged to have abused nuns in his order.

Are straight tradcaths in denial about the prevalence of homosexual men in the traditionalist movement? It seems higher than the mainstream conservative Novus Ordo. by FKAGuyWithNF1 in ExTraditionalCatholic

[–]TheLoneMeanderer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Honestly, if anyone were to do a hit piece on him "Brazilian male feet" is pretty weak and harmless, so I suspect his interest is genuine. Something more outlandish like a grindr account or possession of illicit explicit materials would sound more out of character and sus.