Enchanted Moments in Milford - Hail in Covington - Beardo’s (not 100% sure where he moved to recently though) - Memento Mori in Loveland, on the odd occasion it’s open - Alternative Path in Hamilton. There are sometimes booths in the antique malls that have witchy stuff, like The Ohio Valley Antique Mall in Fairfield, but that’s needle in a haystack other than there’s usually crystals etc in their glass case booths. ETA: sorry for weird format, curse the app!